☕ Daily Brief: VP debate was a shining moment for Trump-Vance
Also, Biden’s warning to Israel
I’m Ari, and this is Upward News. We scoured 100s of sources to bring you stories and insights you won’t find in the mainstream media. Sign up here
SPONSORED BY ALLIANCE DEFENDING FREEDOM
Are there only two genders?
Then a 12-year-old student at Nichols Middle School in Middleborough, Massachusetts, Liam was punished by the school for wearing a t-shirt that says, “There are only two genders.”
WHAT WE'RE WATCHING
🚀 Biden warned Israel not to strike Iran directly, instead favoring sanctions. President Biden discouraged Israel from striking Iran’s nuclear facilities, instead advocating for new sanctions. While Israel is readying an imminent military response, Biden warned against actions that could escalate into a broader conflict that could risk US strategic interests in the region.
📊 Vance made big gains over Walz in the VP debate. A CNN poll revealed 54 percent of independents felt JD Vance outperformed Tim Walz in the vice-presidential debate, despite Walz being favored beforehand. Vance’s strong performance allowed him the opportunity to showcase a new side of himself after being demonized and ridiculed by the press for months.
⚖️ Diddy faces over 100 lawsuits, attorney drops bombshell accusations. High-profile attorney Tony Buzbee revealed that he represents more than 100 individuals suing music producer Sean "Diddy" Combs for alleged abuse, with 25 of the accusers claiming they were underage at the time. Buzbee has gathered extensive evidence against Diddy and promised to expose a list of celebrity enablers involved in the alleged crimes.
🏛 Prosecutors laid out new evidence against Trump in his Jan. 6 case. Special Counsel Jack Smith is arguing that Trump's efforts to overturn the 2020 election were "fundamentally a private scheme.” Although the Supreme Court previously ruled that a president is immune for acts tied to official duties, establishing that Trump's actions were private would leave him more vulnerable to prosecution.
WHAT WE’RE HEARING
IN THE LOOP
The union boss behind the Longshoremen strike has a 7,000-square-foot mansion, a five-car garage, and a Bentley.
The first day of the Longshoremen strike was marred by violence.
President Biden will send 1,000 active-duty troops to North Carolina to assist with the storm damage.
House Republicans introduced a bill to stop taxpayer funding for censorship abroad.
Is the NYC mayor’s indictment Biden-Harris retribution? We break it down here. (Member-only)
Protect your loved ones from fake news. With our Family plan, share access to narrative-breaking newsletters that keep them thinking freely. Upgrade here→
SPONSORED BY BIRCH GOLD
A Message from Donald Trump Jr…
Donald Trump Jr. just went public with his prediction of the damage that “the most socialist ticket in history” will do to America’s economy. In particular, he is warning 401(k) and IRA owners that they need to take evasive action ASAP.
WASHINGTON
VP debate was a shining moment for Trump-Vance
JD Vance spoke with a firm and polished tone, while Tim Walz appeared awkward and unprepared
The two engaged in an unusually substantive discussion focused on the economy, migration, healthcare, and more
Moderators stopped Vance from providing context on the border crisis
The story
Vice presidential picks Sen. JD Vance (R-OH) and Gov. Tim Walz (D-MN) took the stage Tuesday night, addressing key voter issues with a depth that is atypical in modern-day politics. In stark contrast with recent debates involving Donald Trump, this one was substantive and shockingly civil.
Moreover, Vance performed in a way that may prove consequential for the Trump-Vance ticket in November.
These are some of the important topics discussed:
Foreign Policy: Walz highlighted the importance of "steady leadership" that Kamala Harris would provide, contrasting it with what he called Donald Trump’s "fickle" foreign policy.
Vance responded by arguing that Trump's presidency brought global stability, especially in the Middle East, emphasizing that there were no major international conflicts under Trump's leadership.
Illegal migration: Vance criticized the Biden-Harris administration for failing to secure the southern border, pointing to the CBP One app, which helped fast-track large numbers of illegal migrants to gain temporary protected status. He also accused Harris of allowing millions of illegals into the US.
Walz countered by stating that Trump failed to deliver on his promise to build the border wall. Walz also criticized Vance's harsh rhetoric about Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio, stating it sparked fear and alarm in the community, leading to bomb threats that required state troopers to escort kindergarteners to school for their safety.
Abortion: Walz made an impassioned appeal for more lenient abortion laws, arguing that geography should not dictate a woman's access to abortion.
Vance, while labeling the issue complex, called for the Republican Party to regain trust on the abortion issue by being more "pro-family.” He also accused Walz of signing a bill into law as governor that doesn't provide lifesaving care to babies who survive abortions.
Walz responded by misrepresenting the text of the bill, which does precisely what Vance described.
Housing Crisis: Vance emphasized that the housing crisis is exacerbated by the influx of illegal migrants, driving up housing costs and making life unaffordable for many Americans.
Walz disagreed, suggesting that the crisis is largely due to Wall Street speculators and supported legislative efforts to bring down housing costs while providing more resources for migrants.
Vance then promised to provide a Federal Reserve study suggesting migrants may be driving up home prices, which he posted after the debate.
The debate felt like another three-on-one as the moderators frequently fact-checked and interrupted JD Vance while not doing the same to Walz. This occurred in spite of CBS agreeing not to fact-check during the debate.
The politics
From the right, Vance’s performance was seen as a resounding success. Outlets like National Review, Daily Wire, and Megyn Kelly unanimously agreed that JD Vance gave a stellar performance and was articulate and sharp on the issues.
Post-debate polls from CBS and CNN found that viewers believed JD Vance won the debate despite Walz being favored beforehand.
Some left-leaning outlets acknowledged Walz’s painfully awkward response to the Tiananmen Square question.
In 2014, Walz claimed he was in Hong Kong in May 1989 as the Tiananmen Square protests were unfolding in Beijing, but evidence uncovered by the Washington Free Beacon shows he was in Nebraska at the time and didn’t travel to China until August.
When asked about this during the debate, Walz avoided saying that he lied or got the dates mixed up, instead calling himself a “knucklehead” and that he misspoke.
Left-leaning media also attacked JD Vance for suggesting that health insurance should separate healthy and sick Americans, echoing past Republican efforts to reform Obamacare. He later clarified that protections for pre-existing health conditions should remain.
Misrepresented in the media
In one of the most chaotic moments of the evening, the moderators fact-checked JD Vance, as CBS’ Margaret Brennan pointed out that the 20,000 Haitian migrants who have arrived in Springfield, Ohio, have “temporary protected status.”
Vance pushed back on this fact-check, explaining that they gained temporary protected status through the Biden administration’s new CBP One app, which grants asylum or parole to illegal migrants without the typical lengthy immigration process. Vance made the point that this brand new directive from Joe Biden is fast-tracking illegal migrants to becoming legal citizens.
Despite his accurate correction, his microphone was cut off mid-explanation as he tried to highlight Vice President Harris’ role in the illegal migration crisis.
JD Vance, who has often been portrayed as “weird” and combative, confidently pushed back against unfair moderation and steered the conversation toward issues like the economy and immigration, which resonated with voters.
This contrasted with Walz, who often appeared stiff and awkward despite his media-crafted image as a fun, loose, blue-collar dad.
Why it matters
Vance’s ability to remain composed while critiquing the Biden administration may bolster his appeal among undecided voters, while Walz’s missteps could raise doubts about his readiness for the national stage.
Both campaigns have lots of work to do, but Vance’s performance positions him and Donald Trump strongly heading into the final weeks of the campaign.
🎓 Are you a college student passionate about news and eager to break into media? We're searching for driven, sharp-minded interns to join our team. Apply today →
OUR QUESTION TO YOU
📊 Will Vance’s performance help sway independent voters?Poll results will be in Monday's newsletter. |
POLL RESULTS FROM YESTERDAY
Did you prefer the VP or presidential debate?
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️ Trump/Harris Debate (51)
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩 Vance/Walz Debate (710)
⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️⬜️ Other (53)
Trump/Harris: “VP debates hardly move the needle.” — Anonymous
Vance/Walz: “Very respectful towards each other. If only these two were running for President.” — Anonymous
Vance/Walz: “The vice presidential debate was more informative.” — Pete
Other: “Televised debates are just for show and don't really have much substance.” — Anonymous
📊 Want to connect with our audience of 400K+ engaged Americans, conservative voices, and policymakers? See if your mission is a fit →
See you tomorrow.
Today’s newsletter was written by Brandon Goldman and Ari David.