How Epstein Became Trump's Biggest Problem

What’s happening

Jeffrey Epstein has become such a prominent figure in the public imagination that, despite dying only six years ago, his life is already clouded by myth.

The mythology of Jeffrey Epstein goes something like the following:

• He was a pedophile who amassed wealth through suspicious means.

• He cultivated relationships with powerful elites and, aided by Ghislaine Maxwell, allegedly trafficked young women and girls to them, Maxwell herself possibly acting on behalf of Israeli intelligence.

• He secretly filmed these encounters and used the footage as blackmail, potentially for U.S. or foreign intelligence agencies.

• He was arrested during the first Trump administration but was killed in jail under suspicious circumstances, officially ruled a suicide.

How much of this is true? What’s confirmed, and what’s outright false? We wrote this to cut through the noise—from both the left and the right—and make clear where things actually stand in the Epstein saga.

What part of his story is irrefutably true?

Epstein was a math teacher turned financier from New York City. After impressing a parent at the school—the CEO of Bear Stearns—Epstein got a job at the firm handling wealthy individuals’ portfolios. In particular, he helped them avoid or minimize their tax bills.

While there, he managed billionaire Les Wexner’s fortune; he later received power of attorney over Wexner’s assets, using them to obtain a private jet, mansion, and more. Wexner has defended his actions as standard fare for money managers. Epstein made most of his money by taking Wexner and Leon Black—another billionaire—as clients.

After leaving Bear Stearns, Epstein founded Intercontinental Assets Group. This company helped wealthy individuals recover money which had been stolen, winning him friends among the elite.

He was also a pedophile. He and Ghislaine Maxwell—who is currently in prison for conspiring to abuse minors with Epstein—coerced, abused, and raped scores of young girls. Epstein also defended pedophilia to reporters, trying to convince one that “criminalizing sex with teen girls was a cultural aberration.”

Epstein met his accomplice, Maxwell, shortly after her father, Robert Maxwell’s, death. She eventually started helping him procure young women for massages and sexual acts, some of which she participated in.

What parts of the story are unconfirmed?

There is no publicly available evidence that Epstein used videos of powerful individuals as blackmail, for himself or on behalf of intelligence agencies.

However, when Epstein’s New York mansion was raided, the Department of Justice reportedly confiscated CDs labeled “Young [Name] + [Name],” and his various mansions and island were completely wired, leaving a friend to believe Epstein was making videos as an “insurance policy.”

Likewise, there is no direct evidence that he was an intelligence asset. People who knew him say he bragged about being intelligence, but this is second-hand—and he could have been lying.

A famous quote has Alexander Acosta, who oversaw a Florida case in 2007 in which Epstein was charged with soliciting prostitution, saying he had been told Epstein “belonged to intelligence.” But that quote is second-hand at best, having been related to the Daily Beast in 2019 by someone who was supposedly aware of what Acosta had told Trump transition officials.

Still, Maxwell’s father, Robert, was accused of being an agent of the Israeli Mossad. This has never been confirmed by the Israeli government, but he was given a state funeral attended by Israel’s then-prime minister.

Epstein had close ties to Israeli figures like former Prime Minister Ehud Barak, just as he did with numerous other billionaires, world leaders, and celebrities, like Bill Gates and Kevin Spacey.

Some of this is explained by his philanthropy: Epstein frequently gave millions to charitable causes or individuals, winning friends and allies. After his arrest, this led to awkward moments for some, like left-wing analyst Noam Chomsky, who had to explain why Epstein had helped him move nearly $300,000.

What parts of his story are unexplained?

One of the reasons why Epstein has had such a hold on the public consciousness is because some parts of his story have thus far defied explanation:

Why he was hired as a math teacher: Epstein was hired as a math teacher by Donald Barr—the father of former Attorney General Bill Barr—at the prestigious Dalton School. But while he had studied math in college, he never finished his degree.

How he got an Austrian passport: When federal agents raided Epstein’s New York mansion, they discovered an Austrian passport with a fake name and a listed birthplace of Saudi Arabia. His lawyers claimed he received it from a “friend” for personal protection but refused to disclose the identity of the friend or how the passport was obtained.

How he died: The official story is that Epstein killed himself while imprisoned in the Metropolitan Correctional Center, a heavily guarded prison. But that explanation hasn’t resolved the many oddities surrounding his death—like the CCTV footage from his cell being destroyed due to “technical errors,” or his guards failing to conduct a prisoner count that night.

The Trump administration attempted to quell speculation by releasing footage from outside his cell, but analysts have noted that the supposedly “raw” video is actually two stitched clips, with nearly three minutes missing.

Were he and President Donald Trump friends?

Yes. Epstein and Trump socialized frequently in the 1990s and 2000s. But in 2007, Trump banned Epstein from Mar-a-Lago after he hit on a club member’s teenage daughter. Trump was notably the first major public figure to sever ties with him.

So, what are the Epstein files?

The Epstein files are any and all papers the federal government has collected related to the case against Epstein.

The Department of Justice, in a memo released early this month, said the files include “more than 300 gigabytes of data and physical evidence”—which could mean tens of thousands of documents. These files comprise anything related to the investigation, including documents seized in his mansion, such as phone records and contact books.

This is why investigators stress that a person named in the files does not mean they committed crimes: if Epstein wrote down your number on a piece of paper or gave you a call, it qualifies as being “in” the files.

The documents also include “over ten thousand downloaded videos and images of illegal child sex abuse material and other pornography.” Epstein, like other pedophiles, downloaded immense quantities of child pornography.

Is there an Epstein “list”?

The memo declared there was “no incriminating ‘client list.’” Although it has become an object of obsession for some Epstein-info hunters, there has never been any evidence produced to corroborate the idea that a single “list” of powerful individuals compromised by Epstein exists, nor has evidence ever been released proving Epstein sought to compromise others.

Is Trump in the files?

Yes. The Department of Justice has already released some heavily redacted Epstein files. Trump appeared twice there: in Epstein’s contact book and on flight logs from the mid-1990s.

The Wall Street Journal recently reported that Trump was in parts of the unreleased files which were privately described as “unverified hearsay,” along with “hundreds” of other names. The White House denied the story.

Did Trump promise to release the rest of the Epstein files?

Sort of. When Trump addressed the subject on Fox & Friends during the campaign in mid-2024, he was not enthused about the idea: “Yeah, yeah, I would. I guess I would. I think that less so, because you don’t know—you don’t want to affect people’s lives if there’s phony stuff in there, because there’s a lot of phony stuff in that whole world.”

Other statements were similarly wishy-washy on the subject.

What did Pam Bondi say about Epstein?

The attorney general claimed the files were “sitting on her desk” for her to review in February. But later, in early July, she clarified that those files were almost totally child porn, which she said would “never see the light of day.” Bondi added that she had seen no evidence that he was working on behalf of foreign intelligence agencies.

Why is Trump now against releasing the Epstein files?

Trump has said “credible” information should be released, but has been hesitant to release all of it or to talk about the Epstein story further.

While no one can be in the president’s head, part of it may well be what he said on the campaign trail: “you don’t want to affect people’s lives if there’s phony stuff in there.”

If Epstein had fake papers about someone, or even if someone’s name came up innocuously—as Trump’s does in a contact book—they would forever be attached to a known pedophile and would have to spend the rest of their lives proving a negative.

Democrats, who have politicized the Epstein case, will likely seize on any mention of Trump or his allies in the files to imply criminal conduct—even in the absence of concrete evidence.

In short, the Epstein files list hundreds of people who crossed paths with him. Some were likely pedophiles he procured women for—but most were simply acquaintances or contacts with no known wrongdoing.

Why is this so damaging for Trump?

The president is caught between a rock and a hard place. By winking at releasing the files in 2024, his base—revved up for a war on the Deep State—expected big reveals.

But some parts of the files can simply not be released, like the tens of thousands of videos and images of child porn. Others, as discussed, involve names of individuals who are totally innocent.

But if tens of thousands of videos are held back and all the innocent names are blacked out, it will look like something is being hidden—fueling more theories.

What about holding Epstein’s other accomplices accountable?

Deputy Attorney General Blanche was recently sent on a fact-finding mission that included interviewing Ghislaine Maxwell and gathering further details from her…

Become a member to read the rest