Nobody Wants Congestion Pricing As NYC Pushes City To Brink

What’s happening: New York City has implemented a first-in-the-nation congestion pricing program, requiring motorists to pay tolls when entering Manhattan's busiest areas.

Why? The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) wants to alleviate traffic congestion and generate funds for public transportation improvements. Cars face a $9 fee during peak hours, while rates vary for trucks and buses. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) paused the program in 2024 amid political concerns, reducing the toll from an initially proposed $15 to $9 after the elections.

• The details: Some exemptions and discounts are given for low-income vehicle owners — with the caveat of the discount kicking in after the tenth trip each month.

Pushback: The decision encountered resistance, with President-elect Donald Trump and New Jersey officials leading the opposition with attempts to delay it through lawsuits. It didn’t hold, even with the city’s teachers union against the plan.

The numbers: New York Voters overwhelmingly reject the plan. Sixty-three percent of voters opposite it — including 72 percent of blacks, 62 percent of Latinos, and even a majority of Democrats.

Zoom out: New York’s new laws were advocated by ideological environmentalists and echoed similar initiatives in European cities like London and Stockholm. It’s a big step for American cities — and the New York decision could set a precedent for others around the nation.

The brink: The Big Apple is in terrible shape, with recent headlines covering endless murders fueled by the city's migrant crisis. The congestion pricing is a push to get more New Yorkers into the public transport system — which they increasingly view as dangerous. And despite the narrative from Mayor Adams’ (D) office that progress has been made, the crime problem in NYC has largely been unaddressed.

What’s next? Republicans are pushing Trump to fight the program after the inauguration. The looming battle may be one of Trump’s first acts.

In the media

From the left: Outlets like CNN and NBC emphasized the potential benefits of public transit and environmental improvements. Gov. Hochul’s decision was portrayed as a forward-thinking initiative to reduce traffic and fund much-needed updates to the subway system, such as modernized signals and adding new electric buses.

From the right: Breitbart and the New York Post frame the congestion tax as a financial burden on working-class commuters and businesses. The New York Post reported on criticism from local commuters who feel overtaxed. Fox News suggests that the toll harms New Jersey drivers unfairly, while Trump believes it will make New York less competitive and cause businesses to flee.