The MAGA Base Gets Rejected in the Senate

With Senate Republicans electing John Thune (R-SD) as their new leader, they proceeded against the wishes of Donald Trump’s base, who were pulling for Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL). The Senate instead opted for a familiar establishment figure, whom many on the right do not believe will put all of his weight behind passing Trump’s agenda.

The choice, which saw Thune defeat Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) 29 to 24 in a secret ballot vote, demonstrates how the Senate’s leadership elections remain disconnected from the grassroots conservative movement that backed Trump’s rise and continues to fuel his political power.

Senator Cornyn is also viewed by some conservatives as too establishment to represent the new populist wave.

The secret ballot process, a feature of Senate leadership elections, shields these senators from accountability to their constituents. By voting in private, senators avoid facing public pressure from their voters or party activists, escaping the same passions that dominate the House of Representatives.

This anonymity may explain why, despite the palpable frustration from Trump’s base over Sen. Mitch McConnell’s (R-KY) leadership, many Republican senators were willing to back Thune, who is considered to be a close disciple of McConnell’s.

Senator Scott was the first choice for majority leader among Trump’s base and with high-profile names like Tucker Carlson and Elon Musk because of his proven loyalty to Trump’s conservative agenda. However, the Republicans in the Senate thought otherwise, and he was eliminated after the first vote.

Many conservatives feel their representatives overlooked their views by choosing a candidate somewhat unaligned with Trump; however, on Capitol Hill, House and Senate leaders must unify their caucus and facilitate the voting process to be effective. Choosing a leader who is too divisive within the party can destabilize the caucus, making it impossible to move forward with votes.