_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

Derek Chauvin, the former Minneapolis police officer convicted of killing George Floyd, is serving a 22.5-year sentence for felony murder. However, growing calls — including from figures like Ben Shapiro and Elon Musk — urge former President Trump to pardon him.

The case was one of the most explosive in modern American history, sparking nationwide riots, mass protests, and significant policy shifts. But new attention is being drawn to what some argue were major flaws in the trial, the autopsy findings, and the media’s role in shaping public perception.

_THE FACTS_

  • The 2020 death of George Floyd led to nationwide riots that resulted in deaths, billions in damages, and the “Defund the Police” movement.

  • Derek Chauvin was sentenced to 22.5 years for felony murder. His three fellow officers received 3-4 years for aiding and abetting manslaughter.

  • In November 2023, Chauvin was stabbed 22 times in prison by an inmate claiming to act in honor of Black Lives Matter.

  • The original, official autopsy found no evidence of asphyxiation due to police restraint. Instead, Floyd had a lethal dose of fentanyl and methamphetamine in his system, along with severe heart disease.

  • Floyd repeatedly said, “I can’t breathe,” before he was on the ground, contradicting the narrative that Chauvin’s knee directly caused his breathing issues.

  • The knee hold Chauvin used was a Minneapolis Police Department-approved restraint at the time, called the Maximal Restraint Technique (MRT) — a method used on combative suspects.

  • The prosecution’s key autopsy report wasn’t the official one. It was paid for by Floyd’s family and conducted by a pathologist who had previously received $100,000 to testify for OJ Simpson.

  • The jury faced extreme pressure: Some jurors were open BLM supporters, while others were stalked, harassed, and intimidated by journalists.

  • Despite these facts being available since the beginning, major media outlets and politicians downplayed or ignored them.

  • As calls to pardon Chauvin grow, some argue he was convicted in a political trial rather than a fair legal process.

_INSIGHTS_

The death of George Floyd remains one of the most controversial legal battles in modern America. The media played a massive role in shaping the dominant narrative — that George Floyd was murdered because he was black and that Chauvin’s actions were motivated by racism. That framing — still holding strong today — became the foundation for widespread riots, policy changes, and a major cultural shift.

This is why, even if pardoning Chauvin is the right thing to do in pursuit of truth and justice, it carries massive political risks. The media and the left would instantly paint it as proof that Trump and his supporters are siding with a “racist murderer.” Many Americans, having only ever heard the mainstream version of events, would likely see a pardon as extreme, even if the case against Chauvin was deeply flawed.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Bob Hrebec1 year ago

Sad to say but imo President Trump best not touch this one. He's got enough on his hands and this pardon would likely tip the scales too far. Do as is often done and pardon him on Jan 19th 2029.

Avatar

Larry Hemmert1 year ago

I disagree. Time for a revolution. Sick of the violent and dysfunctional people in this country getting a pass while Anglo-Saxon men get rail roaded. Bring it on!!!

Avatar

Laney B1 year ago

Remember when to say "ALL lives matter" made you a Racist? Time to put BLM in the rearview mirror.

Avatar

John Darsey1 year ago

A far better solution, imo, would be a retrial. A pardon from Trump would likely cause more riots like 2020. A fresh trial, however, would shift the spotlight away to focus on the very flawed first trial.

Avatar

Larry Hemmert1 year ago

That is exactly what is needed. But let Pam Bondi preside.

Avatar

Stephen Hoffman1 year ago

The media as you note is the guilty party, but will never admit or atone for its crime. Trump's pardon would do absolutely nothing to "free" the innocent because the state crime and sentence would stay in place. So nothing would be accomplished, and at great political cost, as the media would go bat-$hit crazy. Yes, a pardon of the federal crime upon Trump leaving office is the way to go, as another comment noted. And at that time a statement that the Gov of Minn should issue a state pardon, would be very much in order.

In the meantime, those bringing pressure and publicity of this at Trump's door, need to shift to advocating to Tim Walz. Obviously that will go nowhere now, but keep at it. Use it against him in his reelection bid. He as recently as two weeks ago announced he would not run for Minn's open Senate seat in 2026 and instead seek a third term. This could be a very long fight.

Avatar

Adam Raschio1 year ago

I distinctly remember how one of the major news stations (I want to say it was CNN, but I don't remember for sure) did a news report on the trial that went something like this:

"Such-and-such people have been selected as jurors. For legal reasons, we can't say their names; however, here's pictures of where they live. In other news, this Minnesota senator says that the jurors should be lynched if they acquit Chauvin."

Avatar

J Wright1 year ago

If the President has the power to order a new trial he should do so, otherwise having seen the evidence which is compelling, he should pardon officer Chauvin.

Avatar

Patricia Neumann1 year ago

Pardoning him is the right thing to do since he is obviously innocent, and was framed just like Trump has been framed repeatedly. The political risks should not be considered. What should only be considered is the fact that he is innocent. It is time to do what is right and not care who doesn’t agree.

Avatar

Alc Cookeville1 year ago

Agree, but spread it far and wide the reason for a pardon: that he was given an unfair trial. Better yet, pay for an appeal out of that venue, with full publicity for the reasons and the corporate media and BLM's roles in the mistrial. Make Walz own it.

Avatar

Betty Smith1 year ago

Have him reported dead. Find a way to give him a new identity. Move him to a safe place. Do the same for the other officers.

Avatar

Bernie Peer1 year ago

To me it was obvious George Floyd died of a drug overdose caused by fentanyl. Fentanyl is a respiratory suppressant. I didn’t know about the meth. Meth gives extreme strength and it can be difficult to restrain someone. Think about it 4 police officers were holding him down. I don’t think it is unreasonable that they thought he was trying to escape. Chauvin was made an example of by BLM and the media. It’s there ideology that he came from a poor family and didn’t have the resources white Chauvin had. I reply that does not justify being a criminal. Look at the fall out most major cities have decreased police and many major cities are riddled with crime. 14-15 year old are killing with guns because they get sent to juvenile jail and released. The left and their ideology instead of facts and reasoning have brought this mess. If Trump cares about the rule of law he will pardon him and no public opinion he will pardon him.

Avatar

sharon smith1 year ago

Not a full-blown, public pardon, but a silent release over a short period of time, including name change and relocation of family might work, 'cause his life wouldn't be worth a plug nichol with a pardon. Some extremist would gun him down and then named as a hero for the movement. Even if the evidence against Chauvin is convincing, the BLM movement is still strong enough to make his life a living hell. Where did all the BLM $$$ go? Maybe they will buy his death.

Avatar

Shaun Hurrie1 year ago

This former officer of the law deserves a fair, non-political trial. Anything less is unjust. BLM has simply come out for being what it always was - a money-making, Marxist, race-bating organization that cares little about the rule of law or the late George Floyd (God rest his soul).

Avatar

Nathan Wesche1 year ago

I think Trump is already making too much controversy rather than obvious (and uncontroversial) progress so far. I don't think outright pardoning Chauvin is a good idea. It's the kind of thing that could literally get him killed, plus or minus more major riots. Chauvin, even if he DIDN'T do anything wrong, may have to be a scapegoat.

Avatar

Stephen Winsor1 year ago

It would be better for Chauvin to press for a new trial than have Trump get involved. I am sure that someone, somewhere in the administration or associated with the administration, can obtain the funding and clout to make this happen.

Avatar

Bill Roberts1 year ago

Chauvin was a scapegoat. Floyd was responsible for his own death through an overdose of fentanyl and methamphetamines. He was also a convicted felon who was involved in a home invasion and was also in possession of counterfeit money at the time he was stopped by Minneapolis police. BLM is a racist organization that does nothing for the black community.

Avatar

David McCool1 year ago

No body… should spend a minute deprived of their civil liberties for a crime NOT committed. Alls anyone has to do is purport the facts of this case and transfer yourself in as the alleged perpetrator.

Avatar

Pete Anderson1 year ago

The true victims were Derek Chauvin, those who lost their lives, loved ones, businesses, income, freedom, and neighborhoods, and all law enforcement personnel. Perhaps the attempted cure would only worsen the disease, given the present condition of our society.