_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

Outgoing British Prime Minister Keir Starmer announced plans to ban children under 16 from accessing social media, targeting platforms including TikTok, YouTube, Instagram, Snapchat, Facebook, and X.

Starmer framed the move as "giving children their childhoods back," citing concerns that social media is making young people "unhappy and unsafe." However, some are criticizing the move as an excuse to push through digital IDs and promote left-wing media.

_THE FACTS_

  • Starmer announced that the legislation to ban social media for under-16s would be introduced before Christmas.

  • The ban would not apply to messaging apps such as WhatsApp and Signal, nor to educational services or music streaming platforms.

  • A nationwide consultation received over 116,000 submissions, with 9 out of 10 parents reportedly supporting the ban.

  • YouTube and Meta immediately pushed back, warning that "blanket bans push kids out of curated, supervised, and beneficial online experiences and toward anonymous, less-safe services."

  • Reform UK leader Nigel Farage questioned whether the ban would work, citing widespread VPN adoption and concerns about mandatory digital ID implementation.

  • Elon Musk commented, “This censorship law is a wolf in sheep’s clothing. The real goal is to enable the UK government to track everyone.”

  • The UK government is also reportedly planning to pressure social media companies to alter their algorithms to promote "trusted" legacy media outlets like the BBC and Channel 4.

  • In Australia, where a similar ban was implemented earlier, 85 percent of children under 16 continue to use social media despite the national age restriction.

_OUR TAKE_

On its face, a social media ban for youths seems reasonable, given its incredible addictiveness and the overwhelming evidence of its negative impact on children.

But for the government to ban those under 16, it has to screen everyone. To make this possible, the ban’s advocates are simultaneously pushing for universal digital IDs. As we have dived into previously, these open the door to mass surveillance, forced compliance, and other Orwellian consequences.

The ban has clearly become a vehicle for Labour's wider agenda, including forcing platforms to elevate left-wing outlets like the BBC and silencing those it claims to be “far-right.”

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Michael H.5 months ago

Bans on ANYTHING related to free speech by the government sould NEVER be put in place. If a PARENT wishes to limit their child's screen time its their business...NOT the government.

Personally, I do believe children are exposed to way more on social media than they truly should, but again, it is on the parents to know what their kids are doing and to put any restrictions on their use.

Avatar

Alc Cookeville5 months ago

And the computer and phone apps can allow parents to limit use. It is also possible to avoid IDs by using a VPN. But using a VPN means you trust the VPN to not read your activity and do a profile. And will the VPN provide the government your history? Don't bet on it.

Avatar

J Y5 months ago

Why does every child from ages 5-16 even have a phone? Phones for children should just be for making emergency call or text. Too many parents get their children phones to entertain them. It’s been out of control. Parents have allowed it to be a norm. Now, parents want the countries to create a ban. Make phones for minors simple and easy to use safely. They don’t need all the web content taking them away from sports or studies. Let kids be kids

Avatar

Brooke Nielsen5 months ago

This is a parent’s job. Not the government

Avatar

Don G5 months ago

No. It’s the parents responsibility. Government has shown it is completely useless.

Avatar

Stephanie Channings5 months ago

Absolutely not! This is just the sugar to coat the bitter pill of national digital id - plus , it simply won’t work !

Avatar

Kylee Compton5 months ago

"I'm from the government. I'm here to help......"

Avatar

Photo Man5 months ago

Ya mean to help the gov't bureaucracy. Right?

Avatar

Q C5 months ago

Parents need to wake up and stop trying to rely on the government to parent their children. If you don't want your kids on social media, you have to do the work to put those boundaries in place. We have to stop looking to the government to take on the responsibility of doing everything instead of doing it ourselves.

Avatar

Photo Man5 months ago

That requires personal responsibility. That is something missing these days. Me thunks tis not taught in skool, either.

Avatar

Jorge Rios5 months ago

NO! The way they are going about it is not accomplishing the intended or promised results.

Avatar

Jim Ahern5 months ago

Social Media has evolved into nothing but a toxic echo chamber of propaganda and now you can tack on the AI driven vitriol that has been filling the boards for sometime now. In other words, it's not just about the kids, it's about the platform existing for no other purpose than to stir division, sell lies and promote violence. So if were looking at this from a practical standpoint, why do we even entertain the idea of it's existence any longer? We were doing just fine, in fact much better without it, just 20 yrs. ago. And are we really to believe that a lot of parents in this era are going to make wise decisions regarding their children's content consumption?? Have you met some of these wingnuts out there pretending to be adults? How do you think some of these kids turn out the way they are in the first place? It's not a kids issue, it's not an adult issue and it's not a free speech issue. It's an unequivocally toxic and useless platform application that need not exist, period..

Avatar

Jim Powers5 months ago

After watching my daughter succumb to leftist ideologies, I wish I could walk back decisions my wife and I made to allow her access to social media. For the government to block it, I'm not sure that is a good idea with the 1st Amendment. I definitely would not support some kind of national digital ID.

Avatar

Bob Hrebec5 months ago

No! James must come from mom and dad, not Big Brother. The last thing we need is more government control of individuals.

Avatar

Bob Hrebec5 months ago

Bans not James! Sorry 😕

Avatar

Jen Ed5 months ago

When has prohibition worked? Typical lazy, topical, virtue signalling from the leftists.

Avatar

Jane Robbins4 months ago

Limiting social media access should be the responsibility of the parents. If I were currently raising a child or a young teenager, I would let them have an antique flip phone for necessary phone calls, but absolutely no internet access.

Avatar

Leah MD5 months ago(edited)

Parents need to actually step up and PARENT their children. (I know, what a novel idea!) To me, this is just another way for the government to step in to people's lives and control them. And I don't want the government controlling my children. As a parent, it's my job to teach my children, and to set limits regarding social media, phone use, etc. Too many people are so eager to hand over the responsibility of being a parent to institutions ( ie - schools and government). It's disgusting. And specifically regarding the UK: Considering how poorly politicians handled the "Pakistani Rape Gangs Scandal", even knowing what was going on and doing NOTHING, if I lived in the UK, I wouldn't trust ANYONE in Government to do the right thing about ANY ISSUE! Especially one that dealt with children!!!!!!

Avatar

Martin Nash5 months ago

One has to ask why social media is so addictive to children? Parenting has 2 streams to offer. The old authorative stream of Reward/Punishment is still very prevalent. The child does things to get Love, Approval, Esteem. This enslaves the child to external love and approval. The newer stream is giving the child Unconditional Love and Approval. This opens up the child to be Free to explore, love of learning, creating and contributing. One learns from mistakes, it is not a function of diminishing self-esteem. In the second stream, one does things Because they are loved, not because they have to get love and approval and esteem.

Avatar

Bernie Peer5 months ago

No, it’s the parents responsibility. The government needs to stay out of our lives. That being said schools should have limited access to online. Kids should not have access to social media.

Avatar

Shaun Hurrie5 months ago

Nope! Let parents be parents. Keep government out of banning private homes & individuals.

Avatar

Bill Roberts5 months ago

They will probably pass it but enforcing it is something else entirely. Can’t be done.

Avatar

Terry McCall5 months ago

No the government should stay out of parental responsibilities. That being said I'm in favor of banning cell phones at schools.

Avatar

Jane Spring5 months ago

No…parents are the ones told by God to train their children, not government.

Avatar

David Hooten5 months ago

I believe common sense bans on social media should be done in schools and other learning type environments. I believe parents should be the one's to limit and/or ban social media (and phones) for children depending on their ages. Blanket bans on social media by any federal government can be too much, and it is a bit of a government over-reach.