_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

In a landmark trial that could fundamentally change the future of Big Tech and social media, a Los Angeles jury found Meta and Google liable for designing products intentionally to addict young users. The case centered on a 20-year-old woman, identified as KGM, who claimed she became dangerously obsessed with Instagram and YouTube starting when she was a child.

Meta was ordered to pay $4.2 million in total damages, while Google must pay $1.8 million. The verdict bypassed longstanding legal protections by targeting product design rather than content, potentially opening the door to thousands of similar lawsuits against tech companies.

_THE FACTS_

  • The jury found Meta 70 percent responsible and YouTube 30 percent responsible for the plaintiff's harm, awarding $3 million in compensatory damages.

  • Hours later, jurors ordered Meta to pay an additional $2.1 million and Google another $900,000 in punitive damages after finding both companies acted with "malice, oppression, or fraud."

  • KGM testified that she began using YouTube at age 6 and Instagram at age 9, spending up to 16 hours on the platforms in a single day.

  • The plaintiffs' lawyers targeted specific design features, including infinite scroll, autoplay, and notification systems, which they argued were built to "hook" young users.

  • TikTok and Snapchat were originally named as defendants but settled with KGM before trial.

  • The case bypassed federal Section 230 protections by targeting product design rather than platform content.

  • More than 3,000 similar lawsuits against Meta, YouTube, Snapchat, and TikTok are pending in California courts.

  • One day earlier, a New Mexico jury ordered Meta to pay $375 million after finding the company misled users about platform safety, also finding that it enabled child exploitation.

  • Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg testified under oath during the trial about the inner workings of his company's products.

  • Meta stated it "respectfully disagrees" with the verdict and will appeal, while Google called the case a "misunderstanding" of YouTube as a streaming platform rather than social media.

_OUR TAKE_

This historic verdict shows that social media companies may no longer be free to design apps specifically to keep people glued to screens for hours, with the harms being specifically damaging to children. Countries around the world are already beginning to ban social media for minors, recognizing the harm it causes.

While arguments could be made that such laws and legal decisions infringe on individual rights, it becomes murkier when children are involved, who are not fully developed, and when products are intentionally designed to be as addictive as possible. This trial could force Meta, Google, and others to remove or change these addictive features, fundamentally altering their products and the future of technology.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Bonnie Hissom8 months ago

Call me old fashioned, but where are parents who allow a 6 year old to spend that much time on social media?

Avatar

Photo Man8 months ago

"Is it right to hold Big Tech liable for its addictive products?" YES. All this technology, that goes way, way past the simple basic user friendly features, is an absolutely constant frustrating mental pain!!!!!! I want some simple straight forward feature and the 'engineers' designed all those other absolutely non-relevant features to automatically pop up and get in the way of what I want to read. And too often, many of those auto 'pop-ups' are not a pleasant topic. It is no wonder so many people - not just children - are hooked on this Junk Technology. People, including the software engineers and their host company that employs them, need to get their mind out of the reeking gutter. As an example, Temu ads are everywhere and look at the sexual exploitation they portray upon, especially women. Disgusting! And I have never bought anything from Temu. But it is a constant bombardment with their ads.

Avatar

Jim Harmon8 months ago

Bonnie, you are right to question parents involvement, but I doubt there are that many 6yos spending that much time on social media. Regardless, the fact that the product is designed to promote addiction is criminal when it comes to kids of any age!

Avatar

Doug Ebbecke8 months ago

100% Agree and exactly what I was wondering. Seems cellphones could be blamed if the social media is, as they are complicit by making it available. Restraint by the adults in charge of children are also complicit, so where does the blame game stop and supervision become responsible and self control by those old enough to be responsible.

Avatar

Binh Duong8 months ago

If we will hold companies responsible, parents must be held responsibility as well. No one forces people to use the products. The parents allowed their children to use these products without proper guidance and limitations, so they are responsible as well.

Avatar

Roger Kirkpatrick8 months ago

Though I have great disdain for all addictive online platforms, it goes without sayint that this girl's parents failed her in every regard. META, Google, et.al. could easily make their case, their appeal, by citing failed parenting!

Avatar

Scott L8 months ago(edited)

Do you remember when life was good? When liberals weren't burning stuff all day? When trans ideology wasn't shoved in ever aspect of our lives? All this was brought in by social media. Kill it with fire.

Avatar

Gail Kelly8 months ago

Where were the parents? How did a six year old gain access to the internet without restrictions?

Avatar

Jorge Rios8 months ago

Yes, big tech has had free reign for too long. Although there should be some responsibility put on parents (where were the parents of this child that was allowed to sit and interact on social media for 16 hours a day?) these companies having free reign to purposely design platforms with the intent to addict people, no matter the age, should NOT be permitted. There is no room in todays world for companies to profit from purposely designing products that destroy peoples lives, whether children or adults.

Avatar

Laney B8 months ago

Yes it is right to hold responsible ANY maker of known-addictive product. Zuckerberg has chosen this dark path as his life's work and will be held fully accountable one day.

Avatar

Olin Smart8 months ago

KGM had access to a phone for 16 hours a day at age 6?

Avatar

Susan McCarley8 months ago

Yes, social media, along with public school indoctrination is changing the fabric of our society and needs to be stopped

Avatar

Michael H.8 months ago

Like several others have already stated, these tech companies certainly DO need to be held accountable for the INTENEDED addictive formats they employ. However, parents must also have their feet held to the fire for not monitoring and moderating their children's on-line activities. Ultimately it is up to the PARENT to protect their children from harm. Sadly, most of those parents are just as addicted to social media as their kids and don't understand the level of harm being done.

Avatar

Don G8 months ago

Yes. Adults also get hooked.

Avatar

Jennifer Vaughn8 months ago(edited)

I do support the social media companies being held responsible for deliberately creating addictive features. They were fully aware that their features and algorithms would cause harm to people but they didn't care because they could profit off of that harm. One example, there's a constant barrage of images of physical "perfection" (often images doctored through filters) shown to young people, which causes them to compare themselves in unhealthy ways. Then social media platforms & Youtube offer up solutions to this impossible task of not measuring up; in the form of ads for products to buy AND (horribly) of videos & groups promoting anorexia and binging & purging. And possibly even more horribly, funneling young people toward transgender ideology because some will reject their own bodies when concluding they do not fit into what social media is telling them is "normal" for their gender. ~Jennifer V.

Avatar

Miguel Meléndez 8 months ago

Big Tech should absolutely be held responsible for nefarious practices. I'm 100% for free speech. This is not free speech. It is deception for personal (corporate) gain and targets the vulnerable. I also agree with the many who say parents are responsible. We are parents of 6 and demand accountability from those out to destroy our children as well as from ourselves for teaching and guiding them.

Avatar

Cyndee Pacheco8 months ago

Protect the child, if possible. My grandson would get on the pc after everyone else was asleep. Passwords he would figure out ( he once took money from my account at a remote atm). Surely there’s someway to keep children away.

Avatar

Lori Nord8 months ago

Absolutely! But it's a combination of couch-potato parents and the Big Tech companies only interested in the money. Both should be ashamed and get their acts together! My 12y.o. grandson and I argue all the time about getting off the screen. I tell him all the gaming, etc is "making him stupid". Find a book or go outside!

Avatar

Michael H.8 months ago

I agree that children should be made to go outside on a daily basis. And don't let them take things like hand held games and tablets. You can put parental controls on phones to limit what they can do on them so they have some means of contacting you in and emergency.

I'm not sure the term "couch-potato parents" is the best. Many of these baby makers had very little parental oversight themselves. Their models for raising kids was extremely limited. The decline of parental involvement started with the Boomers and gradually got worse from there.

Government also got more involved with laws dictating what was "appropriate" and what could end up with you in jail and your kids in the foster system. I believe many of todays problems can be traced back to government becoming OVERLY involved in our daily lives. Sadly, a large part of the population is happy letting government control their lives and "taking care" of them. Personal responsibility is a thing of the past.

Avatar

Terry McCall8 months ago

Yes, it's exactly like big tobacco making cigarettes more addictive than they already were. However, parents need to do a better job of protecting their kids as well.

Avatar

Janet Null8 months ago

ABSOLUTELY

Avatar

Garrett Coleman8 months ago

Absolutely

Avatar

M Harrell8 months ago

Yes! And parent too since they allow their kids to have access to the website that isn’t for young age group. Yet, I don’t like what they are doing!

Avatar

JJW JJW8 months ago

Yes. But what role do the parents have in curtailing the over use of the sites. I believe that the ones most capable of stopping abuse of the sites are the parents. JJW

Avatar

Joyce Ramos8 months ago

Simple—trash the devices. It’s a parent’s responsibility. Chances are those parents are also affected and guilty of overuse. So human to pass the blame—Adam and Eve gave us the prototype in Genesis 3:12-13—The woman YOU gave me. The SERPENT deceived me.

Avatar

Janet Young8 months ago

Where were her parents? They should not have allowed her to use the internet at such a young age. Parents are responsible for her usage.

Avatar

Deena Haines8 months ago

So I personally would love to see things change when it comes to social media and children. But as other posters have said, wasn’t this the parents’ fault? Why isn’t she suing them? This whole things gives me weird vibes.

Avatar

Jennifer H8 months ago

Personal responsibility and parental responsibility need to be a larger part of this conversation and equation. I don’t believe this person has a right to such a large financial settlement. The adults in her life who were not adulting bear more responsibility than the platforms. No one has ever said unrestricted internet access was good for children.

Avatar

Jeffrey Beste8 months ago

Let’s not forget the responsibility of any parent who lets their six-year-old get on a phone for 16 hours a day or any age child for that matter. We also need to hold parents responsible for such ridiculous non-discipline.