_WHAT’S HAPPENING_
Socialist New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani (D) is pushing forward with plans to build city-owned grocery stores offering 30 percent discounts on staple items.
The proposal sparked controversy when a city official suggested implementing an ID system to prevent abuse, drawing accusations of hypocrisy from those who noted the mayor's opposition to voter ID laws. Within a week of the backlash, the Mamdani administration reversed course.
_THE FACTS_
The first grocery store is projected to cost $30 million — roughly 15 times what private grocers typically spend.
One official initially suggested a "library-card-esque system" to verify residency and prevent bulk purchases for resale.
The hypocrisy is apparent: Mamdani and the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) oppose voter ID, yet wanted ID for subsidized groceries.
Within a week, the administration reversed course — no ID required, stores open to everyone.
Manhattan Institute's Adam Lehodey called the 30 percent savings "an illusion" — taxpayers will cover the subsidies indefinitely.
Grocery profit margins run 1-3 percent, meaning government-subsidized competition could force local bodegas and small grocers into bankruptcy.
In April, Mamdani said "May the most affordable grocery store win!" — many saw this as a promise to bankrupt private retailers.
The DSA platform explicitly calls for "complete decommodification" of food, housing, and health care — the ideology driving the proposal.
_OUR TAKE_
Government-run grocery stores have been tried before. The Soviet Union built them, Venezuela nationalized its food supply, and Cuba has state stores to this day. The results are always the same: shortages, waste, and a private sector hollowed out by subsidized competition it can't compete with.
It’s only by privatizing the food markets that it has become available, cheaply, for the entire globe. Mamdani knows this, but his leftist ideology is leading him to attempt its "complete decommodification,” which will only end in hurting local business owners for no apparent reason at all.













