_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

Socialist New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani (D) is pushing forward with plans to build city-owned grocery stores offering 30 percent discounts on staple items.

The proposal sparked controversy when a city official suggested implementing an ID system to prevent abuse, drawing accusations of hypocrisy from those who noted the mayor's opposition to voter ID laws. Within a week of the backlash, the Mamdani administration reversed course.

_THE FACTS_

  • The first grocery store is projected to cost $30 million — roughly 15 times what private grocers typically spend.

  • One official initially suggested a "library-card-esque system" to verify residency and prevent bulk purchases for resale.

  • The hypocrisy is apparent: Mamdani and the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) oppose voter ID, yet wanted ID for subsidized groceries.

  • Within a week, the administration reversed course — no ID required, stores open to everyone.

  • Manhattan Institute's Adam Lehodey called the 30 percent savings "an illusion" — taxpayers will cover the subsidies indefinitely.

  • Grocery profit margins run 1-3 percent, meaning government-subsidized competition could force local bodegas and small grocers into bankruptcy.

  • In April, Mamdani said "May the most affordable grocery store win!" — many saw this as a promise to bankrupt private retailers.

  • The DSA platform explicitly calls for "complete decommodification" of food, housing, and health care — the ideology driving the proposal.

_OUR TAKE_

Government-run grocery stores have been tried before. The Soviet Union built them, Venezuela nationalized its food supply, and Cuba has state stores to this day. The results are always the same: shortages, waste, and a private sector hollowed out by subsidized competition it can't compete with.

It’s only by privatizing the food markets that it has become available, cheaply, for the entire globe. Mamdani knows this, but his leftist ideology is leading him to attempt its "complete decommodification,” which will only end in hurting local business owners for no apparent reason at all.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Mike Fankhauser3 months ago

Why would any clear thinking individual fall for this crap? To buy discounted food at a government run grocer, you are basically ripping yourself off. You as a tax payer are paying in the back door for items you pay at the register. The only people that this MAY benefit are those who do not pay taxes (unemployed) and that leads to higher taxes for those that are employed. The fact that this damages free enterprise and will run competition out of the market will end up in food shortages and skyrocketing costs when the government controllers decide that they can simply raise prices without cause or ration whatever the government feels there peasants are not worthy of. Yeah for stale bread and sour milk you idiots!

Avatar

Laney B3 months ago

Aiding and abetting the exchange of freedom for Communism? Not a chance.

Avatar

Mike R3 months ago

No

Avatar

S Lyon3 months ago

This isn’t about lowering prices for citizens, it is a front to launder huge sums of cash to Socialist allies. A superb get rich off the taxpayer scheme. Secondly, would you buy what the government is trying to sell you? Better check those expiration dates carefully.

Avatar

Jim Powers3 months ago

No, I would not support anything so anti-American as this.

Avatar

Diane Carlson3 months ago

Absolutely NOT 💯%

Avatar

Michael H.3 months ago

This ridiculous attempt to have government run markets is a lame attempt to "do socialism right" by these idiots. THERE IS NO WAY TO DO SOCIALISM/COMMUNISM RIGHT!!

There is no way in hell I would ever support this locally. I would take my business to a locally owned store and attempt to help my neighbor stay open.

Avatar

Mike Tucker3 months ago

Hell no I wouldn't. I wonder why it is going to cost $30M to open one store which according to this article is 15x more than a private grocer spends. Corruption is the only answer I can come up with.

Avatar

Ken Cooper3 months ago

You are a 100% right, Mike, and bet your ass that scumbag, mom Donnie will do everything he can to punish those that are actually employing other people at the private grocery stores.

Avatar

Tim in VA3 months ago

Give the communists nothing. No quarter, nothing they can point to as "progress" or a win.

No, I wouldn't set foot in one.

Avatar

Diane Helmuth3 months ago

I kept shopping at our local, small independent grocery store when Whole Foods moved in up the street. Unfortunately, it wasn't enough and they went bankrupt. The small shop owners will wind up with the exact same fate. And by the time the people realize it, the government run grocery store will run into its own issues. At that point, it'll be too late and the local population will not have groceries near them anymore.

Avatar

Tracey Powers 3 months ago

I would boycott any grocery store that fleeces tax payers to subsidize it.

Avatar

Christianne Ortega3 months ago

Nope— Don’t be fooled. Free enterprise and self-propelled charity is the best option for any freedom loving society.

Avatar

Terry McCall3 months ago

I'm in a position where it's not necessary but I understand there are those suffering from food insecurity that might have to. However, the whole scheme is a Socialist scam and will end in disaster.

Avatar

James G.3 months ago

That would be my plan too! I already grow herbs, but would grow vegetables, keep chickens and take up fishing. Basically provide for myself. It would take a major lifestyle change, but worth it… I don’t like being bullied!

Avatar

Mr. B3 months ago

No.

Avatar

Don G3 months ago

May have to as it would be the only one available. Since Islam Muslim people would be in charge, no bacon.

Avatar

Jennifer Vaughn3 months ago

I would not shop there, for as long as possible. I think it won't be too long though until New Yorkers won't have a choice because all other stores will be bankrupt & forced out... which is the true goal. That's the DSA goal for housing too.

Avatar

Chuck Bee3 months ago

I just paid $4.50 for a loaf of bread and $4.00 for 52 oz. of orange juice (it used to be 64 oz. but they shrank the cartons, sneakily maintaining the exact same aspect ratio as the original size). It would be hard to turn away from fairer prices, even though all my "savings" will be added to my income tax. This is just another plan to redistribute wealth.

Avatar

Chuck Evans3 months ago

No.

Avatar

Fred Scott3 months ago

Nope

Avatar

F. Williams3 months ago

I wouldn't buy at a government grocery store unless maybe there were no other options to get good food for my family.

It's terrible what Mamdani is doing.

Avatar

Than Johnson3 months ago

Would depend on prices. We have communities where there are few groceries or just one grocery which charges higher food prices. Competition creates reduced prices not the government subsidies to one grocery and not another. Put and Walmart grocery and a Kroger grocery in each neighborhood and prices will be reduced due to competition. Than

Avatar

S Lyon3 months ago

Wish that were true. Major grocery chains leave these areas for two reasons. Endemic theft without consent and constant violence brought to the store by addicts.

Avatar

Susan Kurzman3 months ago

Grocery stores have a very slim margin of profit. There's very little room for competition.

Avatar

Chuck Bee3 months ago

They should expend some of their energy coming up with plans to get healthy, chronically (and happily) unemployed people back in the workforce rather than providing more free rides.

Avatar

Jim Powers 3 months ago

I’d move to a new city!

Avatar

Michael M3 months ago(edited)

"May the most affordable grocery store win!" WTF!? He has never earned a dollar in his life. Anyone who voted for him deserves what's coming. Perhaps this is what the people who didn't vote, and allowed him to come into power, need to be inspired to get off the couch next time around. But perhaps it is too late.

Avatar

James G.3 months ago

Agreed! And I wonder oh where is the Italian, Irish and Jewish mafias in all this? I’m surprised Mamdummy hasn’t been gunned down yet. Not promoting violence, but he’s threatening the income of mafiosos.

Avatar

Pete Walton3 months ago

Absolutely not!!!