_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

The Dignity Act of 2025, co-sponsored by Reps. Maria Salazar (R-FL) and Veronica Escobar (D-TX) would grant legal status to certain illegal migrants.

The proposed legislation comes amid President Donald Trump's mass deportation policies, which have threatened farms and the service industry in particular, as immigration raids target illegal workers.

The resulting labor shortages have sparked concern among agricultural employers, prompting some Republicans to seek compromise solutions that strike a balance between enforcement and economic needs.

_THE FACTS_

  • The Dignity Act would grant up to seven years of legal status to illegal migrants present in the US since before 2021.

  • Migrants must pay $7,000 in restitution over a seven-year period and a separate $1,000 fee to support American workers.

  • It is similar to a previous bill that Rep. Salazar offered last year.

  • The bill does not directly offer a path to citizenship or access to federal benefits.

  • However, Rep. Salazar acknowledged her bill is a first step toward eventual citizenship for illegals.

  • A separate provision grants permanent residency to illegal migrants brought to the US as minors.

  • E-Verify would become mandatory nationwide to prevent the hiring of illegal workers.

  • Twenty House members — ten Republicans and ten Democrats — have signed on as co-sponsors.

  • President Trump has signaled support for a temporary worker solution, saying farmers should have more control over who they hire.

  • Rep. Monica De La Cruz (R-TX) filed a bill Monday to revamp a temporary worker program and address farm labor shortages worsened by immigration raids.

_INSIGHTS_

Pressure from the agriculture industry is driving this legislative push.

Yet the legal H-2A visa program already allows farms to bring in as many foreign workers as they need, if they’re willing to pay the prevailing wage and provide housing. For many employers, these requirements double their labor costs.

The Dignity Act sidesteps those standards. By granting legal status to the existing illegal workforce, it creates a new, cheaper labor pool for employers, potentially driving down wages for native-born American workers.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Kevin Sargent1 year ago

Slippery slope = BAD IDEA. Start making exceptions in certain industries only opens the gates for others to claim labor shortages. I'll call this NOT a labor shortage, but a CHEAP labor shortage, lowering wages while pushing LEGAL workers Out of the workplace. ILLEGAL IS ILLEGAL, Stop the rationalizing over cherry picked claims!

Avatar

David Landwehr1 year ago

Kevin said it well. If we permit exemptions on illegal behavior, we will only get more illegal behavior. Why reward illegal behavior at the expense of honest immigrants and Americans?

Avatar

Jennifer Vaughn1 year ago

Employers should be required to abide by the current legal visa program. Congress should not be trying to find a way to let them keep a cheap, illegal-immigrant workforce. I'm disappointed in Republicans who are supporting this new bill.

Avatar

Paul Veen1 year ago

Illegal is illegal...they all need to go home. The farm and service industries will survive quite well without them. Any type of amnesty, or selective enforcement, will doom the Republicans in the midterms and beyond. We need Republicans to find a spine and to stop being Democrat-Lite.

Avatar

Charles Williams1 year ago

Congress needs to stay our of deportation. Their interference is comparable to mating elephants, nothing happens without a lot of screaming and it takes two years to get any results. Congress on the right or left has never ever been able to do anything completely and competently.

Avatar

Larry Hemmert1 year ago

DEPORT ALL illegals. Deport all refugees and asylumees . Revoke green card recipients that commit any crime. Revoke citizenship for anyone that lied....that is a socialist, commie or letlftist.

Avatar

Gerard Boes1 year ago

Send them ALL back to where they came from.They broke the law by coming here uninvited and without any sort of legal permission.Millions of people emigrated,or came to America legally.If you break the law coming to Amerca,you have no respect for our laws,therefore,you WILL continue to break our laws....like we see on a daily basis.Experience all that is good and beautiful about the United States,but do it legally.I don't think that's too much to ask.

Avatar

Fred Scott1 year ago

This might have been an issue 25 years ago, when most farms needed laborers to harvest crops. Today, there are many ways farmers can harvest those same crops without human intervention. Only a minimal number of farms would be using manual labor to harvest crops. If necessary, a limited Visa program could be established that allows temporary workers to enter for only the harvest season and return at their own expense.

Avatar

Michael Sarkies1 year ago

Your minimizing of labor requirements is false and not representative of the real issue.

Avatar

Photo Man1 year ago

Fred Scott, you very obviously are not a farmer. H2A visa program is about 60 years old and severely needs updating. But of course our USA political swamp scene cannot get their cooperative act together, not only on this legislation but just about all legislation. However, H2A is meant for temporary (that is a a huge, key word) farm labor, meaning seasonal employment, such as in the fresh vegetable and fresh fruit industry. Which is where these foreign allegiance workers are from. They are needed since the USA young generation does not want to actually work. The employers do follow the vast myriad of time consuming H2A paperwork applications, which is part of the problem. Dairy farming is a 24/7/365 business. H2A does not cover this industry. Yet lots of 'illegals' work on these farms and are very much needed. But the illegals have been able to circumvent the proper 'immigration' laws because Congress, mainly the DemoCommies, cannot get their act together - legally.

Avatar

Greg Berry1 year ago

Not wise. Stand firm.

Avatar

Jim Powers1 year ago

This is NOT what we were promised on the campaign trail. ALL ILLEGALS MUST GO. They are welcome back the LEGAL way.

Avatar

Stuart Denny1 year ago

If there is an adequate legal immigration process, employers should be required to follow it.

Avatar

Jim Powers 1 year ago

Many nations have guest worker programs. I’m not sure we’ve hit on the right solution yet. Elements that would be important to me are: temporary, no path to citizenship, controlled by the individual employer, overseen by DHS and humane treatment.

Avatar

Michael Sarkies1 year ago

Add large fines for migrant and worker violations and permanent deportation for migrant violators.

Avatar

Ed Spooner1 year ago

First, let's be clear - it is a crime to enter the US without proper documentation i.e. an undocumented immigrant is a criminal. Second, the recent violence at the pot farms, as well as many recent street protests, indicate there is a strong and growing sense of entitlement among undocumented immigrants. So, I'm not buying the argument that these are law-abiding residents deprived of that dignity by a broken immigration system. What is broken about it? How many of the longtime illegal immigrants have tried to become citizens? Other comments:

  • Mandate E-Verify - Yes, with stiff penalties
  • H-2A visa program - change prevailing wage requirement to minimum wage.
  • Include a restriction on federal voting rights
  • Payments on $7k & $1k made at an annual check-in; failure =revocation of work visa
  • I don't see any details on enforcement
  • The only path to permanent residency is completion of the citizenship program i.e. NO Amnesty
  • Or, go home and come back the right way
  • Avatar

    Shaun Black1 year ago

    I don't care what roots you've put down. I don't care how long you've been here. I don't care if you're an otherwise productive member of society.

    Get. Out. Of my country.

    Avatar

    Mary Roberts1 year ago

    This is another - sounds good and kind gestures. If employers provide housing and prevailing wage already to foreign workers, then that makes sense. To eliminate those guidelines and instead have illegal immigrants working for less than prevailing wage, plus it seems having to house themselves - that is actually not good or kind. Deportation back to their own countries when they are illegally in the US is the correct action. Then if migrant workers for agriculture are hired for work, follow the rules already in place.

    Avatar

    Laney B1 year ago

    Not at the bequest of (or pressure from!) the agriculture industry whose main goal is to pay low-as-dirt wages!

    Avatar

    Fred Fitzgerald1 year ago

    Als previously mentioned in the article, There is a procedure for farmers to bring laborers into the country to work the farms. One is hard pressed to find articles critical of this practice. So, why is an additional complicated immigration plan for farm laborers necessary? Another administrative elephant to further confuse the situation where two administrative systems would confuse the resolution of a single issue.

    Avatar

    Fred Rogers1 year ago

    A thorough understanding of unintended consequences should be the initial step in sponsoring legislation. It takes vision and backbone to lead.

    Avatar

    Brandon Steinke1 year ago

    No, it is not wise. The rules are the rules. The law is the law. Labor shortage? How about getting all of the twenty and thirty-something’s who are sitting at home playing video games off the couch and I don’t think we would have a labor shortage anymore.

    Avatar

    Laurel Lee1 year ago

    Farmers & other 'Americans' who hire aliens can revise their business plans so they lose an excuse to violate the US Constitution. The 1787 Preamble states clearly that the country is limited to the descendants (posterity) of US founders. Further along, in case anyone missed the point, a provision sets 1808 as the end date for a states' right to import aliens. No provision or amendment transfers the power to the federal government. Another provision & an amendment naturalize preexisting residents of foreign territories the US acquires by conquest & treaty, including slaves. *** Foreign & domestic real estate speculators originated the immigration problem in the 1800s. They got US soil cheap from the US government & only immigrants were fool enough to pay prices that gave speculators big profits. Some US citizens & English counterparts also wanted then & now to get rich in trade with Asia; & they almost certainly sold/ sell out the founders' posterity to cut deals.

    Avatar

    Margaret E Abernathy1 year ago

    Do not ease up ondeportations. If manual labor neededm, use Americans who are onthe dole-nstead making them earn the benefits they are now receiving as freebies. Then if that doesn't work create a specail programs for farm workers with strict complliance of those currently workng on the farms

    Avatar

    Jim Harmon1 year ago

    Illegal is illegal, period! It's easy to lean on that as a policy. While I agree it is a starting premise, I also have to say the 'right' is not always right. While the vast majority of illegal immigrants need and should be deported, there are always circumstances in which the "hard line" is questionable. Where deportation impacts American businesses, consideration is warranted. BUT, exceptions should be rare and only when thoroughly vetted to suggest an exception is the right thing to do. Bottom line, Kevin Sargent is right in suggesting this a slippery slope.

    Avatar

    STEVEN WEATHERFORD1 year ago

    This is a terrible idea. Farming and other businesses need to return to employing US citizens and pay a fair wage. Cheap labor and greed should not be a motive for weakening immigration enforcement.

    Avatar

    Michael Sarkies1 year ago

    Immigration laws and deportation are the correct way to handle violators. Fix the guest worker program to monitor, legitimatize and tax migrants who are willing to participate. Jail or deport the rest.

    Avatar

    Alex RG1 year ago

    Saying ‘Deport them all’ is what happens when someone confuses a Facebook comment section with actual policy. It’s fantasy roleplay for people who don’t understand law, logistics, or basic economics. People like that are unserious.

    We need strong borders and real enforcement. Stop pretending we can deport millions of people overnight. Fix the system, target bad actors, and create a process that works instead of slogans that sound tough but solve nothing.

    Avatar

    Barbara Cousin1 year ago

    How about the dignity of unemployed Americans who can and should do this work.