_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

The Supreme Court issued a 6-3 ruling in Louisiana v. Callais that significantly narrows the scope of the 1965 Voting Rights Act (VRA) in redistricting cases. The justices sided with Louisiana officials who argued that a newly drawn congressional map creating a second majority-black district amounted to unconstitutional racial gerrymandering.

Writing for the majority, Justice Samuel Alito said the VRA does not require states to adopt race-based maps absent strong evidence of past discrimination. The decision is set to create ripple effects throughout the country to the GOP’s benefit — particularly in the South.

_THE FACTS_

  • Justice Alito wrote that Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act "was designed to enforce the Constitution — not collide with it," arguing lower courts have misapplied the law in ways that force states into race-based discrimination.

  • Section 2 of the VRA bans voting practices that discriminate based on race, even if the discrimination isn’t explicit.

  • The ruling requires that evidence of racial discrimination in previous maps be sufficient to establish a "strong inference" before race can be used to draw new maps.

  • Justice Elena Kagan dissented, accusing the majority of a “now-completed demolition of the Voting Rights Act.”

  • The case stemmed from Louisiana's post-2020 census map, which initially included only one majority-black district, even though black voters made up roughly one-third of the state's population.

  • Black voters sued in 2022, arguing the map diluted their political influence by concentrating them into a single district.

  • Alito suggested plaintiffs now often "dress their political-gerrymandering claims in racial garb," expressing concern that Democrats could use voting rights lawsuits for partisan purposes rather than to target racial discrimination.

  • Republican National Committee Chair Joe Gruters praised the ruling as "a win for fairness," while DNC Chair Ken Martin called it "a dark day for America" that "effectively killed Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act."

  • A report from Fair Fight Action and Black Voters Matter Fund estimates the ruling could swing roughly 12 Democratic-held House districts toward Republicans.

_OUR TAKE_

Altio is right to argue that overtly political gerrymandering is often dressed up “in racial garb.” Because minority voters have overwhelmingly supported Democrats since the 1960s, mapmakers can draw more heavily minority districts that function as solid blue voting blocs — portraying these considerations as racial, though it is overtly political. This has been seen in states like North Carolina and Alabama, where courts have found race was used as a proxy for partisan advantage in drawing districts.

With razor-thin Republican majorities in the House and the November midterms approaching, any change in how districts are drawn could determine control of Congress. The ruling gives Republican-controlled state legislatures more latitude to draw maps without creating additional minority-majority districts, potentially giving the GOP a boost during an election cycle that everybody expects will see Democrats overperform.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Charles Williams7 months ago

Absolutely the court made the right decision.

Avatar

david kerkhoff7 months ago

yes

Avatar

Don G7 months ago

Agreed the court made the correct decision. I would hope both parties would grow up start acting like adults and not 10 year olds having temper tantrums. (My apologies to 10 year olds)

Avatar

Salvatore Quasarano7 months ago

Yes they made the right decision! Salvatore Q.

Avatar

Jim Powers 7 months ago

Yes, a little late.

Avatar

Fred Scott7 months ago

Most certainly, this judgment is correct!

Avatar

Michael H.7 months ago

Absolutely YES. The left has been rigging voting maps based on race since the VRA came into existence.

Avatar

Stephen Lykins7 months ago

Absolutely, districts comprised wholly, or even primarily, of any given race are racist!

Avatar

J Y7 months ago

Yes! Unfortunately, today’s leftist will clearly take it “to death” if they don’t get their way. This is a truly horrific temper tantrum. I don’t have the words to express my concern or disgust.

Avatar

Photo Man7 months ago

JY, preach it far & wide!!!!

Avatar

Glenda Noe7 months ago

Absolutely!

Avatar

Chris Carbott7 months ago

This is 100% the right decision! Redistricting is supposed to be about NUMBERS, not COLORS or even Party affiliations. There is no Constitutional justification for rigging the map in order that someone's preferred demographic is guaranteed a seat!

Avatar

JJW JJW7 months ago

Yes, if w can't discriminate because of race, creed and many more reasons, why not make equal voting blocks by population. If a state has 5 million voters divide into 5 or more voting blocks or squares. JJW

Avatar

Linda W7 months ago

Yes!

Avatar

Binh Duong7 months ago

The Islamist-Marxist Democrats are the minority. The only reason the elections appears to be 50-50 is due to their cheating. The Marxist Democrats will not win when we have ID for voting, the voter rolls audited, and in person voting. Why do you think they fight so hard not to turn over their voters rolls? This ruling is correct, because it is wrong to draw these maps based on race.

Avatar

Bob Hrebec7 months ago

Blacks aren't the only ones that can play the racism card! ✊🏻

Avatar

David Hooten7 months ago

Absolutely! We are far past needing racially based remedies. There should be NO racial components any longer.

Avatar

Leon Powell7 months ago

Yes ! Any time someone is given an advantage or disadvantage based only on their race it's racism.

Avatar

Ralph Phares 7 months ago

Based on what I'm able to understand, yes. The Democrats have made no secret they would do anything to win any election going forward and this maneuver smacks of just such a move. James Carville has encouraged the Democrat body politic to do exactly whatever needs to be done to ensure a Democrat win, even if it is illegal.

Avatar

Jim Ahern7 months ago

More and more political games is all this has ever been about since the 60's. Is it really a coincidence that our country has been on a downward spiral since then? Bad people, pushing unreasonable, racial/gender based b.s. policies along the way and evidently nobody truly taking these asinine policies of the past 60 yrs. to task. It just speaks to the pathetic (go along to get along) stance of the Republican Party allowing these anti-American parasites (Socialists/Commies/Marxists - aka Dem Party) to get away with all this crap for these past 6 decades. The beauty is, this is how you fix it by removing the bad actors across the board, not with elections, but by purely identifying there self-character and if out of line with the principles, foundations and moral fiber of our once great country, then your gone immediately and need not apply if your a running candidate. Not that hard to solve in reality..

Avatar

James Coutu7 months ago

Absolutely Democrats manipulating it for years

Avatar

John Fritz7 months ago

YES!

Avatar

Cyndee Pacheco7 months ago

Yes