_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

In the wake of Charlie Kirk’s assassination, the Trump administration has begun a broad-based effort to clamp down on “radical left lunatics,” as described by Vice President JD Vance.

But those efforts recently took an unexpected turn when the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) indirectly threatened ABC after late-night host Jimmy Kimmel made a series of offensive and false remarks about Kirk’s death. Kimmel’s show was pulled off the air indefinitely.

_THE FACTS_

  • This week, Jimmy Kimmel claimed that Charlie Kirk’s killer was a MAGA Republican, despite overwhelming evidence that he was a political leftist.

  • ABC broadcasts on public airwaves via an FCC license, and Chairman Brendan Carr warned the network could be in violation of the agreement.

  • Carr stated that Kimmel’s comments do not reflect the network’s obligation to “operate in the public interest.”

  • Kimmel was suspended shortly after his rant, though insiders insist it was unrelated to FCC pressure.

  • Kimmel’s ratings were already low, and advertisers were revolting over his comments despite Carr’s indirect threat to pull ABC’s license.

  • Carr’s warning followed AG Pam Bondi’s vow to prosecute “hate speech” — a move widely condemned on the Right.

  • Some have cautioned against weaponizing government power, warning Democrats will do the same when they return to power.

  • On the other hand, those in Trump’s New Right shot back: “[Democrats] already did it, and have no reservations about doing it.”

  • White House adviser Stephen Miller insisted the Right must “take all necessary steps to save Western Civilization.”

_INSIGHTS_

Heavy-handed operators like Stephen Miller, who indirectly critiqued Bondi’s comments, have no interest in prosecuting hate speech. However, he and similar-minded Republicans like JD Vance and Brandar Carr are willing to use existing tools in the government toolbox to take action against those they feel are threats to the common good.

The traditional Republican “What if the roles were reversed?” argument no longer holds water for many on the New Right, who point out that Democrats have taken every opportunity to attack the Right for decades.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Jim Harmon1 year ago

I don't support censorship in any form. The only speech that should be held accountable is that which incites violence, such as urging followers to take action against political and law enforcement figures. I think those of us on the right need to push back in a big way. Bottom line is we shouldn't become what we hate.

Avatar

Steve Baker1 year ago

Ditto Jim, I couldn't have said it better myself, so I won't.

Avatar

Laney B1 year ago

They are absoLUTEly correct that DEMOcrats have taken every single opportunity to pervert and squelch conservative voices in the United States of America. My husband's integrity causes him to wish the right wouldn't stoop to DEMO basement-tactics. I, however, think the ship has sailed on gentlemanliness. Sad to admit, but fighting evil with (loud) truth is the only way the right can survive, let alone thrive!

Avatar

Fred Scott1 year ago

In principle, I stand for Freedom in the United States of America! I've seen in the early sixties, the Democratic Party march toward a Marxist agenda. And a desire to control our government and country by the left. The likes of Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, and many other followers of the Marxist Sal Alinsky ("Rules for Radicals"), beginning with President Obama and his corrupt and vile administration deception through a soft voice. This was also evil, in collaboration with radical Muslims, Communists, and Atheists like George Soros! We need to be very careful NOT to follow the desire for control, similar to what the left intended for all of us!

Avatar

Terry McCall1 year ago

We need to fight the Dems with words of truth, not more cancel culture or censorship. Truth will win out in the end.

Avatar

Rich Henke1 year ago

The Democrats have increasingly ramped up weaponization of the Federal government and certain state governments. They have taken to the next level in calling for violence against those with whom they disagree. As pointed out in previous comments in the last few days, "free speech isn't free." It has been bought with the blood of patriots for two and a half centuries. Words have meaning and consequences. Those who abuse the privilege they have in this country should bear the consequences of their words and actions. Calling for any type of violent action against people with whom you disagree should be grounds for termination of employment, being permanently barred from holding public office and potentially for charges of treason or insurrection. Clearly that is my own opinion but maybe it's time for a national referendum on the issue. I know that I am not alone in being tired of left wing wack jobs taking over and destroying our country with the help of left wing wack jobs in congress.

Avatar

Jim Ahern1 year ago

In case you all are missing it, we have a malignant cancer in this country known as the Leftist Establishment. We can't sit around playing boy scout while the Left and it's unchecked street parasites reek havoc in this country. Free Speech is not being violated, that's called censorship as we remember all to well in these past 4 yrs.. Free Speech comes with responsibilities such as not lying to the public, not inciting violence or chaos to name a couple. Hell, the second one is written into law. Kimmel, the arrogant/ignorant prick he is, got what he had coming in this instance. His ratings have sucked, he outraged advertisers with his comments violated policy and cast a knowingly false narrative about the shooter. Yeah, that'll get you shit-canned. Typical Lefty dipshit, always playing the victim card. Good riddance to bad rubbish..

Avatar

Ken Solomon1 year ago

No! That the Dems clamp down on viewpoints they disagree with is no reason to do the same. Instead, we need to demonstrate a better example.

Avatar

Photo Man1 year ago

Ken stated: "Instead, we need to demonstrate a better example." How? What is your proposal Ken? If you have none, than your words are just empty useless words.

Avatar

Mark Van Noy1 year ago

Cancelling speech is the path that lead to Charlie Kirk's assassination. The mentality that speech that offends us must not be allowed to be uttered is absolutely antithetical to the ideals this country was founded on. We lead by example or not at all.

Avatar

Carol Feeney 1 year ago

Absolutely not. Let's not sink to the lowest common denominator by being as back as the woke left was or is. It is time to rise above the swamp and set an example for the next generation as Charlie Kirk was doing.

Avatar

Bernie Peer1 year ago

I don’t think you can just put out that the right is blocking free speech. You don’t have the right to say that you want a political figure dead and then assassinate them. The left shoots down free speech all the time. A man in Washington state went to jail for a year for threatening to kill Patty a Murray. Many on the left say they are going to have right figures. President Trump has had 2 attempts on his life, Steve Scalia was shot… The left has a radical element that is on social media which needs to be addressed.

Avatar

Jim Powers1 year ago

It's dangerous to start censoring any speech. It's a foregone conclusion democrud would use it against the intelligent right but in more ways than just "hate". That word can be defined in so many ways, and they would figure out a way to tie it to normal, everyday talk. I'm happy to see ABC fired Kimmel but fall short of the government being involved. I do, however, believe Erika Kirk and TPUSA need to sue these people out of existence for defamation. Money is the only thing that speaks loudly enough to the left and we need a bullhorn.

Avatar

Jorge Rios1 year ago

The so called New Right should be very cautious in how it proceeds with this. Extremes from either side are not good for anyone, and once travel down a certain road starts it is easy to not realize, with the blur and euphoria of the ride, how fast and how off track the journey has gotten.

Avatar

Photo Man1 year ago

And just what is the "New Right"? If none of you can answer it, than this should be a topic by Upward News to educate us.

Avatar

Bob Hrebec1 year ago

The left has done and said everything imaginable to hurt conservatives and America. If the "New Right" advocates respond in kind......WONDERFUL...... It's about time!!!

Avatar

Steve Baker1 year ago

We can't be shrinking violets, we have to be more assertive but within the boundaries of the Constitution. We have to fight to the last drop of blood in us to save the USA and western civilization, but we can't sacrifice our souls.

Avatar

Amanda Damian1 year ago

No

Avatar

Jim Powers 1 year ago

The proof is in the pudding. Let’s see if it works.

Avatar

Carolynn Bryan1 year ago

Absolutely NOT. Let the left keep talking. The more bizarre things they say, the more people leave their ranks.

Avatar

Bonnie Hissom1 year ago

There’s no excuse for hateful language regarding any tragedy from anyone, especially those in the pubic forum. Yet, our constitution guarantees free speech. You cannot legislate love and compassion or common sense. I’m just thankful I’m not the one who has to decide what’s acceptable or not.

Avatar

Vicki Small1 year ago

Yes, the Left already demonstrated a weaponized federal government. We on the Right did not like what they did. But my mom's words come back to me: "Two wrongs don't make a right." And she never care who "started it."

And yes, I support the First Amendment in all its clauses.

Still, I really would like to see civility returned to public discourse. Charlie Kirk demonstrated so well that disagreements can be discussed without resorting to name-calling or violence. But bother "sides" need to agree to that.

I have a hard time stomaching much of what I hear from the Left. And I want the government to step in forcefully when any voices urge violent or other illegal actions against people who disagree with them. Rioting and all of the destruction associated with riots must be stopped, and those who support rioters and encourage more of the same should be arrested for inciting rioting. That would include members of Congress.

I'm fine with Kimmel's firing. Beyond that...? Maybe not.

Avatar

Jeffrey Burns 1 year ago

Free speech. All of it is protected. Even hateful rhetoric.

Avatar

Ed Spooner1 year ago

Let's review the 1st Amendment: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." I'm not aware of Congress passing any law in recent weeks that prohibits free speech, a free press or peaceful assembly. FCC Chairman Carr, did not violate any law by reminding ABC of the responsibility that comes with a license to broadcast. He could have simply enforced that long established but seldom enforced law. Do I wish he had waited another day, yes. Market forces were already at work and we would have avoided the distraction of discussing it. Disney/ABC did not break any law when they made a business decision that the cost of Mr. Kimmel had far exceeded his value. Many non-celebrities have learned that lesson without a word of public discussion. Free speech isn't free.

Avatar

Alc Cookeville1 year ago

Two wrongs do not cancel each other, but only muddie the water. Free speech is most important and easily lost. There should be no restrictions save against inciting to violence against people or property. Do not become what we know to be evil.

Avatar

Christina Story1 year ago

We should not support censoring speech, not even to "save Western Civilization." We do not protect and preserve Judeo-Christian/Western values by acting contrary to them! The right to think and speak freely applies to all, even when we think what they say is wrong, deceitful, or despicable.