_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

Algorithms designed to maximize revenue are distorting markets across entertainment and energy, prompting President Trump to demand gas stations immediately lower prices to around $2.50, believing they are setting gas prices too high.

These pricing systems let companies quietly charge each customer as much as they can get away with, while making it nearly impossible to know why you're paying more than someone else.

_THE FACTS_

  • President Trump demanded gas stations lower prices "immediately" and ordered the DOJ to investigate fuel price gouging.

  • A federal lawsuit alleges AI software such as Kalibrate — a fuel-pricing software system used across the world — helped California gas stations collude to raise gas prices.

  • Research cited in the lawsuit found this software increased prices by about 6 cents per gallon on average, rising to 30 cents per gallon in markets with high adoption.

  • Kalibrate allegedly discourages users from undercutting competitors, warning that lower prices would trigger a "downward spiral."

  • DOJ has settled lawsuits against RealPage (rental pricing) and Agri Stats (meatpacking pricing) in the past year over similar algorithmic collusion allegations.

  • New York and New Jersey subpoenaed FIFA over similar pricing strategies for World Cup tickets, citing "fake scarcity and impossibly high prices."

  • FIFA's internal staff in the US opposed dynamic pricing for the World Cup but were overruled by leadership seeking to "maximize revenue."

  • A Business Insider experiment found StubHub quoted six different prices to five people viewing identical tickets simultaneously, with fees varying by as much as $66.

_OUR TAKE_

For free markets to remain free, they require transparent prices and actual competition. When algorithms are designed to keep prices high and prevent competition, they're essentially a legal price-fixing scheme — and the savings that should flow to consumers end up as corporate profit.

The fix involves cracking down via antitrust enforcement, which is often unpopular among conservatives. But forcing companies to disclose when they're charging you a personalized price and setting price floors is simply restoring the free market where it’s currently not working.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

David Hooten5 months ago

It depends on the algorithm. The AI pricing models need to be investigated for their structure, and, where necessary, be corrected and the companies fined.

Avatar

Jim Harmon5 months ago

I agree, David, and the fines should be significant.

Avatar

Michael H.5 months ago

I do not trust AI as it is. There are too may issues at this point that must be addressed to put so much faith into the systems. Sadly, people have become accustomed to passing the buck as fast as possible to make someone or something other than themselves responsible for things HUMANS need to be in control of. There is way to much bias in the programing of the AI systems and there needs to be more oversight and regulation until that bias is eliminated.

Avatar

James G.5 months ago

I think what you really mean to say is you don't trust humans. People created AI. With or without it, there will be price gouging regardless.

Either way, I'm with you on this: I don't trust AI, because I don't trust people. The advent of this very topic, validates our/my suspicions about the integrity of the human race as a whole - there is none!

Avatar

Joy Thomas5 months ago

I agree

Avatar

Selene Kitchens5 months ago

AI is bad. Period. Cant trust any of it. Period. Selene k.

Avatar

James G.5 months ago

AI was created by people. It is just another tool; like a pen, a sword, or a suicide drone. It's not the tools fault - it's the PEOPLE!

Avatar

Stephen Lykins5 months ago

Everyone should pay the same price for an identical good or service as everyone else. I do not trust AI but, if it is used in pricing at all, it should only be allowed to set the single price. No algorithm, AI or not, should ever be allowed to set different prices for different customers purchasing identical goods or services.

Avatar

sharon smith5 months ago

Absolutely!

Avatar

Bernie Peer5 months ago

Yes, because it is not a free market. It is reminiscent of socialism and communism. Only the elite can have luxuries.

Avatar

Georges Nidorn5 months ago

Before AI, wasn't gas pricing corrupt as well?

Avatar

Photo Man5 months ago

"Do you think action is needed to tackle AI-driven pricing?" Absolutely!!! I have tracked several commodity exchange prices for decades, with Crude Oil and Wholesale Gasoline prices amongst my favorites. The oil companies have been playing their greedy price manipulation game mightily ever since the so called first energy crisis in '74. Ever since covid, the oil companies definitely show their pure greed. Study their quarterly financial statements. All to enhance their corporate profits and keep their investors mighty happy. I'm glad Trump is initiating going after them.

Avatar

Jim Powers5 months ago

Pricing should never be left up to a computer to determine. These AI tools are pricing things so high that affordability is an issue across the board. AI pricing tools should be as illegal as monopolies are.

Avatar

Fred Scott5 months ago

We must ensure that AI does not harm humans directly or indirectly! And with that, no entity should be able to misuse this power for financial gain over the people!

Avatar

Jennifer Vaughn5 months ago

Personalized/individualized prices for goods, services, rent, etc. set by AI algorithms should be banned.

Avatar

Don G5 months ago

Corporations use any means they can to make a profit. Their stockholders demand this so they can obtain more money. AI is just another tool for them to use. If price fixing is done, proven, then the companies leaders must go to jail.

Avatar

Barbara Cousin5 months ago

No. Get rid of AI first.

Avatar

Greg Berry5 months ago

AI needs to be regulated. Not just certain aspects of it. Evil people will do evil things with it.

Avatar

NoOne WhoMatters5 months ago

A price for an item or service should be the same for everyone. Why should there be differences? AI is a monster that should be reined in and tightly controlled.

Avatar

Cyndee Pacheco5 months ago

I do not trust AI. Period!

Avatar

M Harrell5 months ago

That does need to be investigated! I don’t trust any AI.

Avatar

Jim Powers 5 months ago

The only thing I know about it is what you have written. That’s not enough to form an opinion, but I appreciate the info. I need to learn more.

Avatar

Terry McCall5 months ago

Yes, when competition is removed only the rich will be able to afford ticketed entertainment. It needs to be regulated to bring back competition.

Avatar

James G.5 months ago

I trust AI as much as I trust the pen I use to write with. As much as I trust this computer I use to type with. As much as I trust the phone I use to text with. I trust those tools because I trust myself.

AI is just another tool. It's not AI's fault. It's the a**holes behind it.

Just like the car you drive everyday - you have the option to mow down pedestrians, but you don't. If you did, who would be to blame? The car or you?

  • JG -
  • Avatar

    Doug Ebbecke5 months ago

    Seems AI could be our demise. With all the problems it’s creating out of the gate so to speak. How’s anyone going to control it and make sure it’s for our betterment not our detriment. Definitely concerning!

    Avatar

    Tman Travis5 months ago

    The system need serious investigation and the results passed to the customers, a small cut to investors, but gouging is off the charts, I can't remember last time it $68 a barrel. Yet we in Califorina/corruption 2x 3x cost rest the country

    Just found out last 10 years, Ca. Was charging close to $2.00 for a cap & trade program, (almost $1,000,000,000 collected) yet less than 10% ($77,000,000 was being spent on environmental stuff) Solar panels in La. But over priced and extreme corruption in the $77 mil. Also some of the money was going to support 23 demoncrats, and also a demoncrat door knocker political program. So somewhere to the tune of $750 million unknown destination. Yet if any of Ca. System was honest $2.00 should be removed per gallon just on that corruption alone.

    Not to mention Ca. Is pushing a milage fee estimated to be $4,200 a family with 2 cars. And those in sacramento don't give a crap droves of income earners are leaving