_WHAT’S HAPPENING_

President Trump is threatening new tariffs on Canada after wildfire smoke from nearly 900 blazes blanketed large swaths of the United States, triggering air quality alerts for over 100 million Americans and turning the skies orange.

Trump accused Canada of "willful negligence" for failing to engage in basic forest management, calling the cross-border pollution "totally unacceptable" and vowing to add cleanup costs to existing tariffs.

_THE FACTS_

  • Four Michigan Republican lawmakers accused Canada of underinvesting in forest thinning, fuel reduction and prescribed burns.

  • “This is the third consecutive year we have had to write to Canadian officials about a crisis that Canada has the tools to prevent and has chosen not to.”

  • Trump accused Canada of "willful negligence" for refusing to engage in "basic Forest Management and Debris Removal."

  • Ontario Premier Doug Ford chirped back, saying, "Maybe what you should do rather than complain, is send support, send help."

  • Rep. John James (R-MI) and Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-OH) announced legislation to impose a 25 percent tariff on Canadian imports, with funds directed to a victim compensation fund and cleanup costs.

  • The Air Quality Index hit 248 in major cities in the Northeast and Midwest, among the worst in the world.

  • Major League Baseball postponed Friday's Guardians-Pirates game in Cleveland after air quality reached the "very unhealthy" category.

  • A Canadian Senate report released in June found that "prevention efforts have not kept pace with the growing threat" of wildfires.

_OUR TAKE_

The truth seems to be somewhere in the middle about how feasible it is to prevent such massive fires. On the one hand, the evidence suggests that fire-season (May–September) temperatures have risen over 4°F since 1948, with warmer air making wildfires more likely to catch. And because of Canada’s vast wilderness, it’s unlikely that even with fully competent forest management, these fires could be totally prevented.

But Canada also appears to have neglected proactive management. Many regions of the US are having success using forest thinning and prescribed burns, and the last time the air quality in America was this bad was in 2023 — also from Canadian fires. GOP politicians are right to voice frustration over this.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Don G4 months ago

Everyone is to blame. Those who don’t want to use proven forest management as well as those who complain about cost and don’t want to have their taxes increased.

Avatar

Mark Woods4 months ago

Canada has 2.2 million square miles of forest. That's 60% the size of the US INCLUDING Alaska. The US forests are like a backyard garden compared to Canada's massive boreal woodlands. Manage them? HA!

Avatar

Photo Man4 months ago

"Who/what do you think deserves the blame for the Canadian wildfires?" Trump. He is being his normal pure asinine asshole self when it comes to anything to do with anything Canada. There is no other country that gets treated worse, by Trump, than Canada. Trump needs to learn what the word "respect" means and start employing it. After all, Canada is a very long time US ally and valuable trading partner. I also find it interesting that any so-called right wing news publication never even mentions all the wildfires in Minnesota and Wisconsin, (raging at the same time as those in Ontario,) contributes to immensely also to the wildfire smoke. Sometimes, the right wing political propaganda is as bad as the MSM left wing political propaganda.

Avatar

c. courville4 months ago

Spoken like a canadian...

Avatar

Photo Man4 months ago

No, a U.S. citizen!

Avatar

Scott Connell4 months ago

Please keep with facts and not your personal feelings regarding Trump

Avatar

Photo Man4 months ago

I stated a pure fact about Trump. I am so sorry that I reigned upon your always right supreme dictator king!!!!!!!!! Time for you, Scott, to open your eyes and brain and realize reality.

Avatar

Bob Hrebec4 months ago

Canada is a parasite on the US.....they count on us for their defense. They count on us the build factories to produce goods we buy. And then they cosy up to China.

Avatar

Photo Man4 months ago

"Canada is a parasite on the US" = what do you call China???? They are not even in the same league affecting the US. If Trump in his arrogant asinine attitude would respect and deal with Canada, then perhaps Carney would not have made their recent deal with China. But apparently, Bob, in your view, it is just fine that Trump makes deals with China. You're another one that needs to open your eyes and brain and realize reality.

Avatar

Mark Woods4 months ago

I'm a Canadian living in northern Ontario. All the talk about Canada "managing its wilderness forests" in laughable in the extreme. Has anyone talking this way driven down a Canadian road in the middle of the forest and seen the extensive mile-upon-endless-mile of trees that we have? I doubt it. For sure, Trump and all the state governors complaining haven't. To say that we should manage our wilderness forests is like telling a country somewhere that they should manage the rainstorms that fall on their land because it runs off into another country's territory. It's like little children asking their daddy to stop the crows from cawing because they don't like the sound.

For however much you might not like the smoke and dust in the air, it's called nature. Deal with it. We are.

Avatar

Photo Man4 months ago

Thanks Mark for coming to my aid. Last year, I spent time in Michigan's Upper Peninsula doing photography. For those of you who have never been there, that is a continuous forest on sand soil. Heavily timbered. And lots of cut branches and short logs laying there, to naturally decay over the decades = fodder for a real fire. Then Trump and a bunch of you posters on here, want to criticize Canada for a lack of forest management. How come you are not complaining about likewise in US forests??? Bunch of hypocrites!!!!!!

Avatar

c s4 months ago

lack of forestry management

Avatar

Photo Man4 months ago

Do not give me that excuse. Go look at the US Forests. No better. Remember all the California and western states wildfires from not very many years ago. Also Canada is a huge land mass and a super huge forest compared to anything the US has. And Canada is a very small population and financial resources compared to US. Get a grip people.

Avatar

Wendy Lueder4 months ago

Share and share alike with air quality

During the massive Camp Fire in No cal air quality all the way into the Okanagan Valley here in BC was affected for a couple of weeks as I recall. With hazy skies, smoke and particulate in the air and orange skies. We are all part of North America.

While Canada can admittedly do more to manage their forestry lands and other natural resources, so can the US. I noticed and heard from Californians that the effective forestry practices in the US have also not been maintained leading to more and more massive fires. Don’t worry. Canada did their fair share of complaining when we were receiving the poor air quality.

Maybe instead of playing some weird badminton match with insults, Ford and Trump could have some smart people from every side of the argument sit down and do what is good for North America.

Avatar

Allen Mason4 months ago

Complaining about air quality from natural happenings borders on whether or not the sun will shine tomorrow. Talk about stupidity.

Avatar

Fred Scott4 months ago

Once again, environmental radicalism is idiotic, just like in many places in the USA, where there is poor or absolutely no forest management!

Avatar

Carol Lackey4 months ago

Canada is no more to blame then the US when they have wild fires.

Avatar

Doug Ebbecke4 months ago

Forest management would seem to be the most logical and common sense approach, but green initiatives seem to create issues with both of those philosophy’s. Seems having controlled logging by private logging companies might be a win win for helping the problem to a certain degree. Lessens tax dollars burden, creates jobs, and increases lumber supply which in turn may lower lumber costs and everything that lumber is used for. Probably won’t eliminate the problem but certainly seems like it would be a step in a positive direction.

Avatar

Mark Woods4 months ago

Canada has 2.2 million square miles of forest. That's 60% the size of the US including Alaska. The US forests are like a backyard garden compared to Canada's massive boreal woodlands. Manage them? Good luck.

Avatar

Guy M.4 months ago

Canada is just as responsible for these fires as California was in 2024 when policymakers consistently failed to effectively eradicate, or at least seriously reduce, the voluminous amount of ground vegetation (fire fuel) growing on hillsides that are located in historically windy areas (Santa Ana winds).

Avatar

Sharon Wagner4 months ago

I live in Michigan, one of the hardest hit states for the Smoke. Here, it has affected every single person. When I have to go outside, I can see it, smell it and I can taste it. No blue skies. No open windows. I hurry in and out of my doors to try to keep the smoke out of my home. My air conditioner has been running day and night for days. The worst thing about it is it is hazardous to one’s health. I’m 80 years old and absolutely do worry about being outside at all. I don’t know what the answer is. I realize forest management in Canada is pretty close to impossible, but from what I have read, they don’t too much or anything to try to control forest fires.

Avatar

Mark Woods4 months ago

The problem is, Canada has putting out forest fires as they appear for the last 75 years. Now there's so much dried out timber and accumulated dead lumber that it's basically a tinderbox ready to burn. All that's happening now is that nature has said "Enough!" I gotta burn this old dead stuff. All we can do is sweat it out and hope it ends soon.

Avatar

Bernie Peer4 months ago

Liberalism and poor forest management is to blame. The United States is guilty too! I live in Washington state and when I was a kid in the 70’s we did not have forest fires like this. In our state the first approach is to let the fire burn out and then when it gets out of control declare an emergency. The forests is left alone and the fires are considered part of “the natural process”. Now there is a disease in the forest which kills the trees and leaves the forest more vulnerable to fires. It doesn’t seem like the temperature has gone up so I call BS on that. It seems warmer when I was a kid. DNR minimally clears the forest. There was a fire and the dead, black trees were left up and last winter we had a heavy wind and rain storm and they all blew down to be more kindling. There needs to be more FACT and less idealism in the government.

Avatar

Jen Ed4 months ago

With current drone technology these fires could be both lit and detected. Why aren't they extinguished but left to burn?

Avatar

JR Hill4 months ago

City people talking about rural and forestry problems?!? Living in the PNW forest, far remote and off grid, it is city people who create most wildfire problems. People come to do things that are NOT legal in the city. Then when a problem develops they pack up and go home post haste. Lighting camp fires in the wind, shooting exploding targets and tracers, running without exhaust baffles or spark arrestors and on and on. It is beyond comprehension.

There should be another law.

Avatar

Jonathan Horen4 months ago

Two words: [CA governor] Gavin Newsom

Avatar

Rose Murdock 4 months ago

248 Air Quality Index? It was 987 in Michigan's upper peninsula--Keweenaw County last Wednesday, Thursday! The fire chief there said it actually got to 1000. Then it hovered 600-700 for a few days.