_WHAT’S HAPPENING_
Special Envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff started making moves before President Donald Trump was even sworn in the second time, negotiating between Israel and Hamas over a week before the inauguration. The ceasefire that these efforts produced won him plaudits and gave Witkoff a higher level of exposure than a special envoy would normally have.
But over three months later, a series of questionable statements and ceasefire collapses have made it unclear just how successful he really has been.
_THE FACTS_
Steve Witkoff started off with an early win, securing a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas. Even though he was specifically assigned to the Middle East, he then appeared in negotiations with the Russians, alongside Secretary of State Marco Rubio and National Security Advisor Mike Waltz; Trump’s actual envoy to Russia and Ukraine, Keith Kellogg, was left out.
The jostling for power led some to speculate that Witkoff was sharing foreign policy with Rubio and Waltz. But events of the past few weeks have caused his image to weaken.
Witkoff admitted that he may have been “duped” by Hamas after the ceasefire agreement he helped negotiate broke down.
He was defended by conservative commentator Tucker Carlson, who, in an interview with Witkoff, called the diplomat “the most effective negotiators of my lifetime.”
In that same interview, however, Witkoff left open the idea of a “two-state solution” in the Middle East — something untenable to Israel’s current government.
Witkoff was also defended by the Middle East envoy during Trump’s first term, Jason Greenblatt, who asserted that Witkoff is “thorough, taking calculated risks, learning the landscape, and earning the trust of the players in the region.”
Witkoff has also claimed that Ukraine “agreed” to hold presidential elections and defended Russia’s absorption of some of Ukraine’s territory, arguing the citizens living in the claimed territory were Russian-speaking and had held referendums; he also said Russian President Vladimir Putin was “not a bad guy.”
These latter claims received harsh pushback from Ukrainian media, with one op-ed writing that Witkoff was “willfully disarmed” of knowledge about the conflict.
Witkoff’s recent statements and actions have not engendered any public criticism from his boss, President Donald Trump. But it has led some in the Republican Party, like a major party fundraiser, to call for his resignation.
_INSIGHTS_
Steve Witkoff’s image as a master negotiator has come into question following breakdowns in Gaza and Ukraine, and his recent statements were likely unhelpful for his position. For example, while many residents in the Russian-occupied regions of Ukraine do speak Russian, the referendums held in those areas were conducted under Russian military presence and lacked legitimacy. Statements endorsing these referendums will only lessen Witkoff’s credibility in the eyes of the Ukrainian government.
Likewise, publicly opening the door to a two-state solution will likely encourage Hamas to keep fighting; while the first Trump administration did embrace a two-state solution, it is unclear if the administration still supports that plan (it is completely off the table for the Israelis) — and admitting he was “duped” by Hamas may also complicate efforts to build trust with Israeli officials, who likely want to work with diplomats who won’t be tricked.












