WHAT’S HAPPENING

An independent security review released at the end of September concluded that Utah Valley University was totally unprepared for the shooting that killed Charlie Kirk last year.

The 158-page report detailed major security failures, including inadequate staffing, poor coordination with Kirk's organization Turning Point USA, and critical delays in alerting students to the active shooter.

THE FACTS

  • The independent review found UVU had only six officers on duty from its 13-member police force during an event that drew several thousand attendees.

  • TPUSA controlled ticketing and told planners to expect around 600 attendees when actual attendance was "several thousand."

  • Kirk's team insisted on holding the event in an outdoor Fountain Courtyard despite university concerns about controlling access to the area.

  • No line-of-sight assessment was conducted to check for sniper vantage points, and a planned security walk-through between university police and Kirk's security detail never happened.

  • Campus officials took 19 minutes to send the first campus emergency notification after the fatal shot was fired.

  • Available lockdown tools went unused, and there were no bag checks, metal detectors, or a drone sweep of the area, including of nearby rooftops.

  • The university issued six contradictory emergency alerts over just over an hour, confusing students and staff about whether to evacuate or shelter in place.

  • The Utah System of Higher Education approved a systemwide security review last week with dozens of recommended improvements.

  • Utah's higher education system is requesting $5 million from the state legislature to hire a statewide campus safety coordinator and fund various security upgrades.

OUR TAKE

It's shocking to see just how unprepared the university was, not only for Charlie's event but for an emergency of any kind. The response from the campus was delayed and unclear, and it’s totally unacceptable that campus police and TPUSA's own security failed to secure the area thoroughly enough, leaving the shooter with a direct line of sight from a nearby rooftop that easily could have been scouted and secured.

Both sides share the blame, since the university had only six officers on duty, while TPUSA vastly underestimated the crowd size and didn’t provide enough security to see who was actually attending.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Bonnie Hissom1 month ago

Everybody who should have been looking out for Charlie. But playing the blame game gets us no where. We must learn from this experience so it doesn’t happen again.

Avatar

Wendy Sproule1 month ago

It doesn't matter now. Charlie is gone and we can never get him back, to our infinite sorrow. RIP, dear man.

Avatar

Fred Scott1 month ago

Laying blame seems to be the theme of our time; let lessons be learned to help prevent these terrible tragedies from happening again. Take responsibility and more on!

Avatar

Mike Tucker1 month ago

No one and everyone is to blame. I'm not seeing the blame put where it belongs. On the shooter, on leftist ideology(political violence is OK), on mental health, and trans/gay activism.

Avatar

Photo Man1 month ago

"Who deserves the blame for the security failures leading to Charlie Kirk’s death?" I agree with Upward's "Our Take". However, it needs to go further. This is a result of a sickened culture with no morality and the leftist radical liberals openly promoting, endorsing and executing 'murder'.

Avatar

David Hooten1 month ago

As you adroitly reported, TPUSA underestimated the crowd size, and the University was inadequately staffed. Also, the University didn't do a thorough job of recognizance.

Avatar

Michael H.1 month ago

The unfortunate thing is there is PLENTY of blame to go around. Technically, TPUSA is not responsible for the campus security but, knowing the current atmosphere with violent attacks on conservatives, including multiple assassination attempts on Trump, they should have been more assertive in making sure the security details were properly handled. I do not like thinking that many of the universities Charlie visited had STAFF who were hostile towards him and that may have played a part in their lax attention to security for the event. It truly is sad and scary that having a contrasting political view can put a huge target on you, LITERALLY. I pray these attacks are unsuccessful in the future, for ALL involved.

Avatar

Salvatore Quasarano1 month ago

UVA and TPUSA both failed in protecting Charlie!!!!!!

Avatar

Julia Bortz 1 month ago

The man who shot him is to blame. Don't have dilute the blame that belongs to this individual. Learn from it. Lone wolves will continue to try and silence people. Protect the speaker.

Avatar

Randy Carleton1 month ago

I loved Charlie Kirk. He was unique, yet he was a debater, not someone running for office or someone rational people would think needed a lot of security. Yet now we have to consider that. It’s a horrible lesson we’ve learned. I agree with all those who are expressing the blame game.

Avatar

Dennis Marchant1 month ago

Progressive haters who hate America, Israel, and Christians. If they win the upcoming mid-term elections America will be in dire straights. May God protect us from Progressives.

Avatar

Terry McCall1 month ago

Both are guilty of inadequacy if the facts, as you reported, are true. Changes need to be made in both organizations.

Avatar

Bernie Peer1 month ago

Well, I think the brunt of the responsibility is on his own security team. They should have scouted the area, they should have had drones patrolling before and during the event. That does not leave the university without responsibility. It seems reasonable after President Trump being shot from a building that would be a reasonable place to look. I think what all need to remember is there are 2 little girls without a daddy.

Avatar

Jane Spring1 month ago

Who would have imagined it happening? Now we can and security must be strong on every side.

Avatar

James G.1 month ago

No one is. Charlie trusted the Lord first and foremost. Just because we see this as a fault by humans, it doesn’t mean it was a fault by God.

Charlie is exactly where he needs to be. I’m done squabbling about our inequities. Our Lord and Savior wanted him home.

‘Do not conform to the pattern of this world.’ Romans 12:2

Avatar

Jennifer Loving1 month ago

Everyone that failed to protect him!