_WHAT’S HAPPENING_
The White House Religious Liberty Commission held its first public hearing on antisemitism on Monday, though it quickly descended into a fight over Christianity and Judaism.
What was expected to be a subdued gathering of testimony from Jewish Americans became contentious when commission member Carrie Prejean Boller, a Catholic conservative activist and former Miss California, challenged witnesses on the definition of antisemitism and defended right-wing commentators Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson from accusations of Jew-hatred.
Boller, who wore a pin combining the US and Palestinian flags, pushed back on testimony linking anti-Zionism with antisemitism and questioned whether opposition to Israel should be considered bigotry. The exchange has sparked calls from pro-Israel figures for her removal from the commission.
_THE FACTS_
Prejean Boller told panelists she had counted 17 mentions of Israel during testimony and asked if any would condemn "what Israel has done in Gaza."
Boller just recently converted to Catholicism in April 2025.
"Catholics do not embrace Zionism, just so you know. So are all Catholics antisemites?" Prejean Boller asked the panel, drawing boos from the audience.
She defended Candace Owens, saying, "I listen to her daily. I haven't heard one thing out of her mouth that I would say is antisemitic."
When Babylon Bee CEO Seth Dillon called Owens and Carlson "the two most famous antisemites," the crowd cheered.
Dillon responded that Owens "goes far beyond not merely supporting Zionism," noting she often denigrates Jews directly.
MAGA influencer Laura Loomer accused Prejean Boller of "harassing Jewish panelists" and predicted she would be fired from the commission.
Following the hearing, Prejean Boller posted on X: "Forcing people to affirm Zionism on a 'Religious Liberty' Commission is the opposite of religious freedom. I will not resign, and I will not be bullied for following my Catholic conscience."
Separately, multifaith groups sued the Trump administration on Monday, alleging the commission violates the First Amendment by excluding non-Christian voices.
_INSIGHTS_
The commission was designed to protect religious freedom, but Monday's hearing showed how online battles between conservative Christians and Jews are now playing out in official government settings. What was supposed to be a straightforward discussion about antisemitism became an embarrassing spectacle about whether Christians must support Zionism to participate in interfaith coalitions.
The fact that Prejean Boller holds an official government position while defending figures accused of antisemitism creates an awkward situation for the administration, which has positioned itself as strongly pro-Israel while also accommodating various factions within its base.












