_OUR GUEST_

Israel Ganz is the governor of the Binyamin Regional Council, which oversees the largest Israeli-controlled area in Judea and Samaria — otherwise known as the West Bank.

A long-time advocate for Jewish life and security in Judea and Samaria, Ganz plays a major role in shaping Israeli policy on settlements and advocates for advancing Israeli sovereignty over the entire contested region.

As tensions escalate and Iran and its proxies grow more desperate, protecting Israeli communities will become even more critical. And while some in the US push for a two-state solution, Ganz believes a Palestinian state in Judea and Samaria would inevitably endanger Israeli lives.

_WHAT WAS DISCUSSED_

  • Why Israel’s settler leadership sees October 7 as a turning point for sovereignty

  • The data behind Arab support for the Hamas massacre

  • How foreign governments are funding illegal Palestinian construction

  • How the PA pays families of terrorists — and why that matters for policy

  • Why the two-state solution is viewed by many Israeli leaders as suicidal

_THE INTERVIEW_

This interview was edited for clarity.

Ari: The situation in Judea and Samaria is something that, for sure, not many understand.

Can you give your opinion on how the media views what’s happening here — what they call “settlements” in Judea and Samaria, or the “West Bank” — and what they’re missing about the reality?

Israel: I like people like you who understand that the situation is very different from what’s shown in the media, and who want to show the reality to the people. So, thank you for that.

It’ll take time to fully answer your question, but I’ll try to make it short. What was the biggest mistake we made on October 6, the day before October 7?

We knew about the terror. We knew everything about Hamas. We trained for it. So why were we so surprised?

The mistake was thinking that if we gave them money — whether from Qatar or elsewhere — they would build a future, prosperity, peace. We were wrong. We didn’t understand that this is a religious war.

They hate America. They hate Israel. It’s not about their situation in Gaza. They took billions of dollars and instead of helping the people, they used it to build tunnels and missiles.

And here, in Judea and Samaria, it’s the same.

How do I know? I’ll give you facts. First, we have polls. One published on October 9 — just after the war began — showed that 86 percent of Arabs in Judea and Samaria supported the Hamas massacre.

The Palestinian Authority (PA) pays salaries to terrorists. If you kill Jews, your family receives a lifelong salary from the PA. They build neighborhoods where you can get an apartment if you murder Jews.

PA police have trained in Afghanistan. I can show you videos. They jump from planes, they carry RPGs. I’ve never seen a police officer in DC or New York with an RPG. That’s not police — it’s military.

After we killed Sinwar, they held a meeting and called him a hero. So we’re dealing with the same people here. They want to kill me and kill you.

Let’s continue with facts: since the war began, the IDF has killed over 1,500 terrorists in Judea and Samaria — people trying to attack our communities and soldiers. Over 15,000 people have been arrested. That’s 20,000 terrorists either arrested or killed in this small area.

The army operates every day and night. Just recently, they found a bomb factory in Jenin — bombs to kill people like me and you. And they march in the streets everywhere — “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.” What does that mean? It means no Israel.

The head of PA policy is also the head of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO). The PLO was founded in 1965 — before the 1967 war, before Judea and Samaria. What was its goal? To remove Jews from all of Israel.

These people want to kill us.

When was the last PA election? 2006. Why hasn’t there been another in 20 years? Because they know Hamas would win. Hamas, the Muslim Brotherhood, Islamic Jihad — they’re all here.

When I host people here and they speak about a two-state solution, I ask — Are you crazy? Gaza is 20 kilometers wide. Judea and Samaria is 350 kilometers — stretching from Be’er Sheva to Hadera, across from Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, and more.

We couldn’t stop 6,000 terrorists from crossing 20 kilometers in Gaza. What will happen if hundreds of thousands attack from 350 kilometers away?

When people talk about a two-state solution, I hope they wake up to the realities of October 7. Because we were always saying — it would be a terror state. It would be an Iranian arm, firing missiles at us.

There will never be a Palestinian state here. Never. We must have full security control. If we don’t, we’ll be attacked. No airplanes will be safe.

We must declare: the goal of terror is to frighten us, to remove us from here. But this is historically and legally part of Israel.

If Arabs want to live here, fine. But only under one condition — no terror.

Ari: On the international law part, the global media narrative is that Jewish settlers are moving in, breaking international law, and disrupting everything.

I think The New York Times even claimed that Israel’s killing of Sinwar may have violated international law, which is outrageous.

Last week in Hebron, I was shown a map by some hilltop settlers. It showed how Palestinians are also building illegal settlements and rapidly populating the land. Some Israeli settlers are trying to slow that growth.

I didn’t realize how quickly the Arab population is expanding in Judea and Samaria. Can you speak to that?

Israel: First of all — facts and law. I had a podcast with Natasha Hausdorff, a lawyer, and she explained clearly that under international law, Israel has the right to be here.

The original British Mandate’s goal was to establish a Jewish state. When Britain left, Jordan came in — illegally. Jordan doesn’t claim rights here anymore. So, who are the Palestinians? Where did they come from? There was never a Palestinian state.

So when people talk about “occupied territory” — occupied from whom? Jordan? Jordan doesn’t want it. They admit they were illegal here.

About six years ago, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo came here, just 300 meters away, and declared that settlements are not illegal. The US recognized that claim.

According to the Oslo Accords, Area C is under full Israeli control — security, municipal, everything. Yet Palestinians have built over 103,000 illegal structures in Area C — homes, farms, roads.

I’ll show you a picture I took in Binyamin. It shows illegal construction funded by foreign countries — Belgium, Switzerland, others — under the UN flag.

Imagine if I built something illegally on a New York road and put up a sign saying, “Donated by Israel for poor people.” People would lose their minds.

Yes, we are working very hard to build and expand here. We returned from exile. This is historical justice. Every place you go here, you see our history.

We’re not settlers — we came back to our homeland.

Here, look at this — an illegal neighborhood, and people moved in.

Ari: They just put up a UN sign.

Israel: Exactly. “Support Palestine.” “At risk for forced transfer.” Funded by the European Union. Ireland, Belgium, Luxembourg — you name it.

Ari: Are they really getting money from all these global NGOs for illegal building?

Israel: Yes. In Area C.

Ari: When I was being driven around, my guide pointed out: “This village is funded by this UN body, that one by the EU...”

They’re just funding Arab villages to build illegal settlements.

Israel: Yes. Area A and B only cover around 20 percent of their population. They have enough room to build there. But they build on our roads in Area C. It’s not random — it’s war.

Just like Gaza: instead of hospitals and infrastructure, they build caravans on our land. That’s the situation. I have more meetings waiting for me.

Ari: Are they just trying to rush now and grab as much land as they can?

Israel: 100 percent. For 10 years.

I’ll send you a video — please translate it. A PA leader from 2009 says clearly: “We will build illegally in Area C. No one will stop us.” He even publishes annual reports of their illegal work.

He has 600 employees working in Area C — illegally — under his office. Yes, they’re working hard. And we must work harder to apply Israeli sovereignty. It’s the only way to stop the terror.

Ari: I spoke to some Knesset members, like Simcha Rothman, who said it’s time to formally recognize that sovereignty. How close is Israel to doing that?

Israel: That’s a difficult question.

We just opened the Knesset session. There are many issues — especially with Iran.

But I can tell you: we will work hard to try to make it happen in this government’s term. I don’t know if we’ll succeed, but we’ll try.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

David Hooten1 year ago

Israel should take over the West Bank; it was theirs at the inception of the Jewish state.

Avatar

Monty Mickle1 year ago

That's right!

Avatar

Ken Solomon1 year ago

Yes. The status quo means that Israel will eventually lose control over Judea and Samaria. Israel needs to claim their land before the Arabs take it by fiat.

Avatar

Shoshana Levine1 year ago

Israel will need to take a strong stand against the illegal occupation in Area C. With so much going on now it is lower on the list. I think it is proven they do not want a homeland for their people they just want Israel gone.

Avatar

Jane Spring1 year ago

Israel can defend their homeland from the river to the sea…God promised it to Israel. (GENESIS 15:18-21. The land of “Canaan” which includes Gaza and Israel today.) I am a Christian and my faith is based on the Jewish man, Jesus, coming back to earth one day, to Jerusalem. Many don't understand the reason so many Christians support Israel.

Avatar

Betty Smith1 year ago

Yes. We will be praying they succeed quickly with God’s help.

Avatar

SGT USMC1 year ago

Israel has the strength to take control of the region—not for conquest, but to free millions trapped under terrorist rule. Why should entire populations suffer under Hamas, Hezbollah, or corrupt regimes that use them as shields while attacking Israel? This endless cycle of launch and retaliate only brings pain. If Israel expands to secure its borders and liberate these oppressed people, then yes—take them over. Give them the same chance at peace and prosperity that Israeli citizens enjoy. In Israel, Jews, Muslims, Christians, and others live together under rule of law and real freedom. That model should spread. The goal isn’t destruction—it’s liberation. Israel bringing stability means fewer rockets, fewer dead civilians, and more hope for those who’ve known nothing but war. Freeing them doesn’t just protect Israel—it gives an entire generation a future.

Avatar

R Button1 year ago

Israel needs to take full control of all of the region known as the “West Bank” and fully annex it into the nation. This needs to be done for their security. No two-state solution! One day, within seven + years…this will take place.

Avatar

Rae Miles1 year ago

Why 7+ years?

Avatar

Eleanor Iford1 year ago

It’s time for Israel to stop trying to be “fair”. The Palestinians don’t care about laws or rules. They don’t value human life. Israel must stop playing by the rules and eradicate the terrorists from Israel. Clearly a 2 state plan won’t work, Hamas won’t stop until Israel no longer exists. Golda Meyer said “If the Arabs lay down their arms, there will be peace. If Israel lays down their arms, there will be no more Israel.”

On another point, what’s happening on university campuses must be stopped as well. We need to hang screens and play footage from October 7th until it gets through to the kids exactly what they are supporting.

Avatar

Larry Hemmert1 year ago

Yes. Oust all muz. Build a wall. Outlaw Islam.

Avatar

F. Williams1 year ago

Israel should absolutely proclaim sovereignty! Judea and Samaria belongs to Israel by international law and, most importantly, by God's law! Terrorists don't care if they die; the only way to win against them is to assert sovereignty over the land.

Avatar

Laney B1 year ago

Yes 💯%‼️

Avatar

Magvitum1 year ago

The "West Bank..." is ISRAELI!!! It was theirs from the beginning of time! Longest than these usurper muslims ever existed. Their return will be such a plus for humanity! Instead of warring people who keep their own enslaved people hungry and ignorant, Israel is constantly providing humans new amazing inventions and possibilities in medicine and all other areas of life.

Avatar

Eric Hill1 year ago

They should take any and all land that belongs to them

Avatar

Eleanor Gibson1 year ago

It is part of Israel!! We should take total control AND bring in industry. Working men do not have time to build bombs

Avatar

Bob Hrebec1 year ago

A two state solution will not work. So long as Palestine exists there will not be peace.

Avatar

claude chase1 year ago

The question was: ( Should Israel take full control over Judea and Samaria? ) My answer is: God has commanded it to be done. that is unless I misunderstood my bible reading ? if I remember right the Jewish people complained about the promised land of milk and honey not being fulfilled, as best I recall God's answer was to the effect that You have not yet cast off the problematic people living at your side. the implication seeming to be that once that has been done, the land will flow with milk and honey as promised !

Avatar

John Smith1 year ago

Both Judea and Samaria are an integral part of the Jewish Homeland. Ludicrous decisions to split the region and call it the west bank, are simply political decisions by anti Israel entities, including the now much discredited UN, who want to take Israel piece by piece away from its rightful owners.

Avatar

Russ Shoemaker 1 year ago

I think that would be a very great move, love it ! Russ S

Avatar

Terry McCall1 year ago

I hope the political will is there to make all of Samaria and Judea part of Israel. The terror will not stop until that happens.

Avatar

Vicki Small1 year ago

Yes, Israel needs to take full control of Judea and Samaria. Problem: They are tied up in fighting in too many other areas to be able to concentrate troops, arms, armaments, planes, and probably funds, to be able to focus as they ought in the West Bank.

Avatar

Bennett Machanic1 year ago

There will NEVER be a two-state solution, and it is high time to seize the entlre West Bank. Our feckless prior leaders before President Trump were terrified at the concept of confronting the realities in the Middle East. This is the time to rectify the prior mistakes. We need to support the elimination of the "Palestinian Authority", as there is NO such entity of "Palestine" which is merely a vehicle to kill Jews and Christians.

Avatar

Monty Mickle1 year ago

Isreal is the only side that has truly advocated a 2 state solution, which would be suicidal for them since Palestinians have always advocated the destruction of Israel. Time for Isreal to come to its senses and support Isreal as the one state solution. Go Israel!

Avatar

Jonathan Werdenberg1 year ago

Yes, Israel should take over the Gaza Strip and the West Bank to reinstate its ancestral boundaries!

Avatar

Janet Null1 year ago

YES !!! ABBA-solutely

Avatar

Michael Bozzone 1 year ago

I don’t think that the Israelis have a choice in this. They need to take full control if they want to be safe.