WHAT’S HAPPENING

A civil lawsuit alleging a Cornell student was gang raped by seven Chi Phi fraternity brothers in 2024 has ignited a brutal fight over due process and consent.

The case, in which local prosecutors initially declined to bring charges, is now in the hands of New York Attorney General Letitia James after Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) lost confidence in how the local DA handled it and after mass outrage erupted online.

THE FACTS

  • The plaintiff, called “Jane Doe,” filed a civil lawsuit in September alleging seven fraternity brothers drugged and gang-raped her at the fraternity house two years ago.

  • The Tompkins County DA initially declined to prosecute, saying Doe's original statement to Cornell police didn't meet New York's legal standard for sexual assault.

  • A transcript showed Doe told Cornell police she could say "with 100 percent confidence I was raped," language the DA claims he never received.

  • Doe's original statement described consenting to threesomes, telling investigators she showed up to the party already “5 out of 10” drunk, and was “pretty ok with having this threesome.”

  • Doe describes using ketamine at the party, even snorting a line off one of the males’ body.

  • At 1:42 a.m., one of the brothers sent a message about “free” sex upstairs to a Snapchat group entitled “Chi Phi Actives.”

  • After consenting to sex with the first two males, she later claims to have been uncomfortable when more showed up, saying it “felt like coercion.”

  • Two days after the sexual encounter, Doe texted one of the accused that "none of the sexual stuff was illegal" and suggested meeting up again, but "leave out the extra 5 billion men and ketamine."

  • She then wanted to attend a Halloween party back at the frat house, but the brothers wouldn’t let her come.

  • In a police report a month after the incident, Doe recalls thinking during the encounter: “If I do Ketamine again, maybe I will pass out. My thought was that if I passed out and these men had sex with me, then they could be charged with rape.”

OUR TAKE

Firstly, Letitia James as special prosecutor is deeply troubling. She has a track record of politically motivated cases, and this appointment doesn't inspire confidence that the process will be impartial.

Getting to the heart of the matter, it’s clear that the behavior from the men involved was disturbing, especially advertising “free” sex to the other fraternity brothers. Yet the timeline suggests Jane Doe did not believe she was raped until after she was socially rejected and her reputation was being destroyed. She even wanted to meet up again with one of the brothers and wanted to attend another party at their fraternity.

As more evidence surfaces about what happened later in the night, a clearer picture should form of whether a sexual assault occurred or whether a degenerate and gross situation just got out of hand.

See more Upward News in Google: add us as a preferred source

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

BAD RLTR1 month ago

Whoever messaged "free sex" is an idiot and should suffer the worst penalty. From the facts available, I don't think a crime was committed. But this entire saga should be a cautionary tale to all men; when a woman is under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol, you need to be EXTRA careful about obtaining AND maintaining consent. Obviously the first few guys were fully consented to, but the her consent to the later guys stands on shakier footing.

Avatar

Mark Van Noy1 month ago

Way back in the 20th Century, when I went to college, they had mandatory training sin the dorms informing all students that it was impossible for a woman to give consent if she was inebriated. I believe that was codified into law in California. It is possible that all the men involved are legally guilty of rape event if she verbally consented given that she claims to have arrived at the party inebriated.

Morally, everyone involved, everyone, is reprehensible in my opinion. I cannot muster any sympathy for a single soul. This reads like a woman who had no regrets until she was socially scorned then decided to use a rape charge as revenge. Letitia James just loves herself some lawfare so I expect her to run with it.

Avatar

Samuel DuPlessis2 weeks ago

BAD RLTR. You should be ashamed of yourself. The barrier for sex should not be "obtaining and maintaining consent". We should have sex in a committed marriage between a man and a woman. All the of the fraternity brothers and women involved with this situation and any other drug and sex party should repent of destroying themselves and our nation with it. If my son comes home after having sex at a party with a woman and another man and tells me "but I had consent" I couldn't begin to describe how disappointed I would be. You should live your life to serve others, not have random drug fueled sex. If my daughter told me that she was upstairs at a sex party I couldn't begin to describe my disappointment. We should not be doing these things. We should not join sex party fraternities. God help us!

Avatar

Q C1 month ago

I have a crazy idea, I’m sure no one (especially those more religiously inclined) have ever heard of it before: how about we decide as a society that sex should just be between a man and a woman in a loving, committed relationship (called marriage). I know this is a crazy, revolutionary idea and it might not even make any sense since it’s so out there, but maybe, just maybe, it could be a good idea… At the very least it would prevent something as deranged as this (ie group sex with drugs and/or alcohol involved and questionable “consent” from the woman)

Avatar

Vicki Small1 month ago

Yeah, a silly idea, to many. But it was a good design. Sadly, I don't expect we'll ever get back there.

Avatar

Samuel DuPlessis2 weeks ago

Amen!

Avatar

Bonnie Hissom1 month ago

Too many loop holes in the story, but it sounds like a real eye-opener about what goes on around college campuses - drugs & sex.

Avatar

D C1 month ago

Always. Nothing new about that. Though I'm not sure group sex has been in the past.

Avatar

D Curtis1 month ago

No, I don't believe a crime was committed. Low class behaviour exhibited by all involved. Not impressed by "college students".

Avatar

Photo Man1 month ago

"Do you believe a sexual assault occured at the Cornell frat party?" According to the information presented by Upward, the answer is No. She very willingly got what she was after.

Avatar

Bernie Peer1 month ago

Yes, when a text was sent for free sex that’s when the rape occurred. It’s disgusting that the text was sent and that they knew she was drugged. Really is the animalistic society we have become? This is so disgusting

Avatar

Brian Oneill1 month ago

The alleged victim didn’t seem to think so.

Avatar

Don G1 month ago

Society at large is the underlying problem. If it feels good, do it.

Avatar

Vicki Small1 month ago

You can't sue society at large. I would agree that these college "students" are immature and not morally astute. Perhaps they ought to go home, work at a job for a couple of years, maybe even five years, until they've matured some and can go back to school with an academic and career goal in mind. Could even save some money toward tuition and books..

Avatar

K More1 month ago

Jane Doe’s sworn statements to the police at the time clearly state she consented to all the behavior including the sex and drug use. Anytime she asked the men to stop they stopped. While everyone’s behavior was disgusting and repugnant, regretting your actions and the resulting damage to your reputation doesn’t make it sexual assault. It’s just the consequences of your actions.

Avatar

KT E1 month ago

I have an unpopular question to ask: if these guys were also drinking and snorting were the guys any more or less accountable than the girl?
Obviously there was foul behavior here - but I’m trying to understand the legal basis by which fault is being measured. Morally - there’s so many egregious violations across the board- but that’s not legally binding.

Avatar

Vicki Small1 month ago

Every guy involved is as accountable as the girl. Whether they were legally culpable is another question. She did willingly use the drug and give (legal?) consent to multiple partners. Dumb on their part to take advantage of her altered mental state, but their brains aren't yet fully developed in the areas of judgment, assessment, and thinking about possible consequences. That isn't an excuse.

The more I think about it, the less sure I am that her complaint is bogus. A. There should have been no drugs or alcohol at the party. The guys who brought those in ought to face criminal charges on providing them. They ought also to be kicked out of the fraternity. The fraternity ought to be suspended, at the least. B. The guys did know she was using drugs and they may, in fact, be legally culpable for having sex with her, when she was not clear-minded. State laws may say they are. The girl also needs to face consequences from the school, but no more harsh than what the guys ought to face.

Avatar

Photo Man1 month ago

"The girl also needs to face consequences from the school, but no more harsh than what the guys ought to face." = Excuse me, but "she" is the instigator of this whole gross situation. The overall huge responsibility is with "her". Yes, it is disgusting what the guys participated in, but it still comes back to "her" raging hormones and she absolutely received what she desired. They all deserve a big rap but she certainly deserves the biggest one by far. But typical modern day woman, they enticingly commit their own acts like this and then years later, want to blame some guy. And "she" expects the judge to side with her and let her walk free again, as if she is now a new reborn virgin. SICKENING!!!!!!!!!

Avatar

Kays N1 month ago

From her statements, it seemed she consented to maybe the first two guys, but as she was very heavily under the influence of drugs and alcohol, and based on the later text messages exchanged between the men, it does seem the later ones are very heavily insinuating sexual assault.

Avatar

Guy M.1 month ago

I have little sympathy for any person involved in this debauchery. It's the story of an already drunk woman who compounds the issue by taking ketamine, along with a bunch of horny young men sowing their wild oats. She knew what she was doing and only filed the lawsuit after her reputation as a slut was being sullied.

Avatar

Aesop Wise1 month ago

When the accuser's story changes, and then solicits public outcry, belief in any of it diminishes quickly.

Avatar

Doug Ebbecke1 month ago(edited)

Seems like a complete collapse of moral character are all participants part. A bit where at times it seems the countries headed. But based on the article seems no is guilty of anything other than being dumb and lack of character.

Avatar

Bob Hrebec1 month ago

It reads like she was ok with it until the guy she wanted rejected her and her reputation got damaged. They were smart to not let her come to their Halloween party....she was trying to set them up.

Avatar

Terry McCall1 month ago

It all sounds gross and indecent but also like she consented. Hopefully everyone involved learned some valuable lessons.

Avatar

Michael H.1 month ago

The "me too" movement created a scenario in our justice system that called for people to UNQUESTIONABLY accept the woman's word when she gave her report as ABSOLUTE TRUTH about what happened. There have been way too many instances of false allegations because of this mentality. YES, women lie about things to gain attention or be vindictive for a relationship that didn't work and ended poorly.

Avatar

Linda Holevinski1 month ago

All this information was available the FAKE media again runs without investigating. The whole incident is terrible and indicative of how much our society has deteriorated.

Avatar

Karen C1 month ago

This is such a bizarre case. While the accuser consented to the activities, one has to question if she has any self-respect. And the answer to that is “NO”. Additionally, the males appear to have absolutely no moral or ethical compass. Poor (legal) choices, still should have some sort of consequences. Begs to ask the question; who raised these kids? Based on the evidence released to date, there hasn’t been a crime committed, just really poor judgment all the way around!!

Avatar

Thomas Peeler3 weeks ago

Why are the males named but not the female? The whole lot are disgusting.🤢