WHAT’S HAPPENING
A civil lawsuit alleging a Cornell student was gang raped by seven Chi Phi fraternity brothers in 2024 has ignited a brutal fight over due process and consent.
The case, in which local prosecutors initially declined to bring charges, is now in the hands of New York Attorney General Letitia James after Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) lost confidence in how the local DA handled it and after mass outrage erupted online.
THE FACTS
The plaintiff, called “Jane Doe,” filed a civil lawsuit in September alleging seven fraternity brothers drugged and gang-raped her at the fraternity house two years ago.
The Tompkins County DA initially declined to prosecute, saying Doe's original statement to Cornell police didn't meet New York's legal standard for sexual assault.
A transcript showed Doe told Cornell police she could say "with 100 percent confidence I was raped," language the DA claims he never received.
Doe's original statement described consenting to threesomes, telling investigators she showed up to the party already “5 out of 10” drunk, and was “pretty ok with having this threesome.”
Doe describes using ketamine at the party, even snorting a line off one of the males’ body.
At 1:42 a.m., one of the brothers sent a message about “free” sex upstairs to a Snapchat group entitled “Chi Phi Actives.”
After consenting to sex with the first two males, she later claims to have been uncomfortable when more showed up, saying it “felt like coercion.”
Two days after the sexual encounter, Doe texted one of the accused that "none of the sexual stuff was illegal" and suggested meeting up again, but "leave out the extra 5 billion men and ketamine."
She then wanted to attend a Halloween party back at the frat house, but the brothers wouldn’t let her come.
In a police report a month after the incident, Doe recalls thinking during the encounter: “If I do Ketamine again, maybe I will pass out. My thought was that if I passed out and these men had sex with me, then they could be charged with rape.”
OUR TAKE
Firstly, Letitia James as special prosecutor is deeply troubling. She has a track record of politically motivated cases, and this appointment doesn't inspire confidence that the process will be impartial.
Getting to the heart of the matter, it’s clear that the behavior from the men involved was disturbing, especially advertising “free” sex to the other fraternity brothers. Yet the timeline suggests Jane Doe did not believe she was raped until after she was socially rejected and her reputation was being destroyed. She even wanted to meet up again with one of the brothers and wanted to attend another party at their fraternity.
As more evidence surfaces about what happened later in the night, a clearer picture should form of whether a sexual assault occurred or whether a degenerate and gross situation just got out of hand.















